Reflection on Reading #17: The Heterosexual Questionnaire by Martin Rochlin, Reading #18: Disability Definitions: The Politics of Meaning by Michael Oliver, and Reading #52: What Can We Do? Becoming Part of the Solution by Allan G. Johnson
As I was reading The Heterosexual Questionnaire by Martin Rochlin, I found myself getting angrier with each question I read. Not because I was offended by the questions, but because I was mortified by what the author terms the "straight" frame of reference. This questionnaire really put into perspective what gays and lesbians have endured intellectually and emotionally as a result of our oppressive and discriminatory frame of reference. As I was reading each question, I thought how in the world is this appropriate to ask of anyone? And reversing the questions perfectly highlights the inherent hypocrisy related to our way of thinking as heterosexuals and the implications associated with that mind set.
Looking at question #10: "A disproportionate majority of child molesters are heterosexuals. Do you consider it safe to expose your children to heterosexual teachers?" The logic of this question is obviously flimsy and highlights how ridiculous these surveys are. I began to wonder what a questionnaire like this would be used for? Why would we make lesbians and gays answer questions like this? To apply for a job? To apply for housing? What?
I was reminded of a story I recently heard on NPR about a gay teacher who was loved by his students. On the last day of school he was brought before the administration and "let go." It turns out he was being fired because he was gay and a post on Facebook revealed that he was getting married over the summer to his long time partner. He was devastated along with his students. Would this ever have happened to a heterosexual person posting about their wedding on Facebook? Obviously not...but such questions highlight the hypocrisy of heterosexual dominance in our society today and this makes me want to become part of the solution to this problem.
Similarly, in Michael Oliver's article, Disability Definitions: The Politics of Meaning, we are reminded that definitions are important in our society. He says, "Disability has both individual and social dimensions...The problem with this, is that these schemes, while acknowledging that there are social dimensions to disability, do not see disability as arising from social causes," (p. 168). This article was interesting because it does show that disability does not stem from a person's functional limitations, but rather from the organization of society. Oliver reminds us that social and economic forces have a direct cause of disorder. People with impairments are not chosen at random but rather a series of social and economic circumstances play a part in that impairment. "Just as we know that poverty is not randomly distributed internationally or nationally, neither is impairment...," (p. 170). This challenges all ideas that impairments are happening only to unlucky or unfortunate individuals. This is a notion that we all need to stop and think about.
In What Can We Do? Becoming Part of the Solution, Johnson reminds us that we will probably not see change in patterns of oppression and discrimination in our lifetime; however, we can alter how we "see ourselves in relation to a long-term, complex process of change," (p. 504). I like this idea because sometimes it is easy to get discouraged and think that what we are doing is not enough. But, "if we are going to see ourselves as part of that kind of change, we can't use the human life span as a significant standard against which to measure progress," (p. 504). This is so true. I like thinking about how as a collective whole we are working towards change that shifts the path toward challenging the values and mind sets that systems of privilege depend on. I have worked with an organization that helps abused women living with domestic violence. After seeing my cousin lose her life to domestic violence, I know that the work we are doing is not in vain. However, there have been times when I wasn't so sure. With so many women coming in daily, I wondered how we are making a difference. But then I think about how we are "contribut[ing]to the slow evolution of entire cultures so that forms and values which support privilege begin to lose their 'obvious' legitimacy and normalcy and new forms emerge to challenge their privileged place in social life," (p. 506). If the work that we are doing provides new pathways for the children and grandchildren of diehard misogynists and abusive men, then I know I am doing the right thing. And even if it doesn't, I have faith that I am doing the right thing and on the right path.
Johnson, A.G. (2012). What Can We Do? Becoming Part of the Solution - Reading #52, 6th Edition.
Oliver, M. (2012). Disability Definitions: The Politics of Meaning - Reading #18, 6th Edition.
Rochlin, M. (2012). The Heterosexual Questionnaire - Reading #17, 6th Edition.
No comments:
Post a Comment