Wednesday, July 16, 2014

Final Course Reflection

As I reflect on this course, I realize that I have learned a tremendous amount about diversity...really eye-opening and empowering ideas.  Before the class began, I thought that I already knew what diversity was and why it mattered in our world.  However, as each class built on the previous one, I realize that I wasn't even close to knowing what diversity is.  I have learned that diversity is much more than what we "see."  Diversity is a complex idea that encompasses so much more an individual's visible attributes such as age, race, ethnicity, gender, and physical characteristics.  In fact, diversity includes a person's invisible attributes not readily seen such as sexual orientation, social class, educational background, parental status, socioeconomic status, religious beliefs and affiliations.  And, yet, there is still more to consider in terms of social diversity.  For example, an individual's sex may be invisible to us as we read about intersex individuals in reading #10: Where's the Rulebook for Sex Verification and reading #11: All Together Now: Intersex Infants and IGM.  This was a revelation to me as I never even considered that people might not be what they physically and biologically looked like.  Disability is also another master status that we need to consider when we are talking about diversity.  I was struck by the idea that "...definitions of self vary with the context; how others try to define one as belonging in a particular category; and how, in many ways, one's very presence calls prevailing classification systems into question," (Rosenblum & Travis, 2012, p. 3).  Realizing that people possess more than what we "see" was eye-opening to me, especially in terms of race, and gave me a sense of empowerment to think about diversity and its social constructions in a new way.  I learned that what matters most is how a person perceives their own individuality and identity.  This course has not only enlightened my views about how I see myself and others, it has truly changed me as a person.

Reading personal narratives about different people's experiences with diversity was life changing. Take, for example, Sally French's experience in her article, "Can You See the Rainbow?"  The Roots of Denial.  I was really affected by her story and how she had to deny her disability in order to ease other's anxiety and disappointment and to gain acceptance into her world.  And while this should never happen to anyone, let alone a child, how many more stories did we read about individuals living with similar circumstances?  This indicates that we need to be doing more in our society to bridge these differences and help to improve practices of everyday life.  When I read about Lily Ledbetter, Eulalie Cooper, William Upski Wimsatt, and how Rosa Parks inspired a movement other than the civil rights movement, I was encouraged.  Looking at the ideas of diversity as a group with an open dialogue energized me in ways that I never thought possible.  Exploring the issues associated with race, social class, sex, disability, and so on opened me up to new possibilities for understanding and bonding with others precisely because we are different.  I realize that we all have one commonality and that is that we are all different.  We are all individuals.  However, because we have all most likely experienced some form of discrimination in our lifetime, we should be able to talk about those experiences collectively and in a way that acknowledges how we can change it.  Similar to Gandhi's paradox, we can't change everything but we certainly have the power to change some things...starting with ourselves.  "We make the road by walking," (Machado, 1875-1939, p. 481) and that is powerful to think about because the sentiment conveys that we blaze the trail as we go and that, yes, we will most likely make mistakes along the way...but that's alright.  We won't always have the answers but at least we are trying to make a change.  That change, I believe, will come from education.  As Rosenblum and Travis (2012) highlight, "Learning changes us, and higher education is explicit in its intention to produce that effect," (p. 481).  This is certainly the case for me after taking this course.

So, what are the aims of diversity?  Examining this guiding question through the following four course objectives has enabled me to come up with an answer as well as a vision for how I can affect future social change.

Knowledge:  
Reading our text, The Meaning of Difference: American Constructions of Race, Sex, and Gender, Social Class, Sexual Orientation, and Disability, has opened my eyes to the complicated and multi-faceted issues of diversity.  The framework essays have exposed me to ideologies and terms that I have never encountered before and, for that, I am grateful.  I wonder how I have gone this many years without knowing some of these theories and how they relate to history, politics, and the law in terms of social diversity and our constructions of it.  Furthermore, it was fascinating to see how these theories and research translate across different cultural and national settings.

Strategy:
My strategy for using appropriate methods of inquiry stem from becoming a better critical thinker.  I will strive to gain a better understanding through examining and questioning of the issues.  Acknowledging and understanding that the media has a profound influence on our everyday lives will enable me to find a greater balance between fact and fiction.  Looking at everything through a critical lens will also help me to figure out who is benefiting from certain actions and who is being harmed.  I believe that is critically important because the media paints a skewed picture of information and if we don't question it, then we are forced to take things at face value.  This is not how "we make the road by walking," (p. 481) and not how we will transform the world.

Perspective:
I believe that I now have a more informed perspective of the social constructions of diversity because of this class and the reading I have done.  In order to convey this perspective, I will encourage an open dialogue about the issues of diversity and difference with my colleagues, students, parents, as well as my own family in order to foster a culture of collaboration.  This, I believe, will ultimately lead to an even more informed perspective about the practice of diversity in our society.  Listening to others and their experiences will be a big part of my strategy as I move forward.

Vision:
My vision entails the following:
  • Create an inclusive environment wherever I am, whether that is in the classroom or at home.  
  • Listen to others and their experiences in order to reserve judgment
  • Create a culture of collaboration among colleagues, students, and parents about issues of diversity
  • Talk to my own kids and family about diversity and why it is important to keep an open heart and mind
  • Continue to read about issues of diversity through scholarly articles and books
  • Stand up and speak out for what is right
  • Become more politically active and aware
  • Understand that I will make mistakes along the way but know that it is all a learning experience
  • Reflect upon my experiences in order to become a better educator, activist, and human being
  • Appreciate myself for who I am and the statuses that I occupy   

To me, the aims of diversity are to recognize, value, and embrace the uniqueness of each individual. When we do this, we are creating an inclusive environment where all people feel respected and understood.  Using education as a means to facilitate social change is critical because we can use the lessons that we learn and transform them into action.  The children of today will be our leaders of tomorrow so it is imperative that we teach them about social diversity.  

In life, we will find that people whom we believe are “just like us” are more different
than we think, and people we perceive as “different” have a surprising amount in common with
us.  It is important that we take time to reflect on people we consider to be “just like me” and see if we can identify ways in which the person is different from us.  Conversely, it is equally important to reflect on people we consider to be “different” and see if we can identify ways in which the person is like us.

In the end, we need to remember that "we both make society and are made by it," (p. 481). Therefore, we must believe in and utilize the power of education for meaningful social change and this starts with each and every one of us.


Rosenblum, K.E., & Travis, T.C.  (2012).  The meaning of difference: American constructions of race, sex, and gender, social class, sexual orientation, and disability, 6th edition.  McGraw-Hill.


For more information about social diversity, please visit http://aimsofdiversity.weebly.com/          

   

Monday, July 14, 2014

Reflection on Reading #17: The Heterosexual Questionnaire by Martin Rochlin, Reading #18: Disability Definitions: The Politics of Meaning by Michael Oliver, and Reading #52: What Can We Do? Becoming Part of the Solution by Allan G. Johnson

Reflection on Reading #17: The Heterosexual Questionnaire by Martin Rochlin, Reading #18: Disability Definitions: The Politics of Meaning by Michael Oliver, and Reading #52: What Can We Do?  Becoming Part of the Solution by Allan G. Johnson

As I was reading The Heterosexual Questionnaire by Martin Rochlin, I found myself getting angrier with each question I read.  Not because I was offended by the questions, but because I was mortified by what the author terms the "straight" frame of reference.  This questionnaire really put into perspective what gays and lesbians have endured intellectually and emotionally as a result of our oppressive and discriminatory frame of reference.  As I was reading each question, I thought how in the world is this appropriate to ask of anyone?  And reversing the questions perfectly highlights the inherent  hypocrisy related to our way of thinking as heterosexuals and the implications associated with that mind set.  

Looking at question #10: "A disproportionate majority of child molesters are heterosexuals.  Do you consider it safe to expose your children to heterosexual teachers?"  The logic of this question is obviously flimsy and highlights how ridiculous these surveys are.  I began to wonder what a questionnaire like this would be used for?  Why would we make lesbians and gays answer questions like this?  To apply for a job?  To apply for housing?  What?  

I was reminded of a story I recently heard on NPR about a gay teacher who was loved by his students.  On the last day of school he was brought before the administration and "let go."  It turns out he was being fired because he was gay and a post on Facebook revealed that he was getting married over the summer to his long time partner.  He was devastated along with his students.  Would this ever have happened to a heterosexual person posting about their wedding on Facebook?  Obviously not...but such questions highlight the hypocrisy of heterosexual dominance in our society today and this makes me want to become part of the solution to this problem.  

Similarly, in Michael Oliver's article, Disability Definitions: The Politics of Meaning, we are reminded that definitions are important in our society.  He says, "Disability has both individual and social dimensions...The problem with this, is that these schemes, while acknowledging that there are social dimensions to disability, do not see disability as arising from social causes," (p. 168).  This article was interesting because it does show that disability does not stem from a person's functional limitations, but rather from the organization of society.  Oliver reminds us that social and economic forces have a direct cause of disorder.  People with impairments are not chosen at random but rather a series of social and economic circumstances play a part in that impairment.  "Just as we know that poverty is not randomly distributed internationally or nationally, neither is impairment...," (p. 170).  This challenges all ideas that impairments are happening only to unlucky or unfortunate individuals.  This is a notion that we all need to stop and think about.

In What Can We Do?  Becoming Part of the Solution, Johnson reminds us that we will probably not see change in patterns of oppression and discrimination in our lifetime; however, we can alter how we "see ourselves in relation to a long-term, complex process of change," (p. 504).  I like this idea because sometimes it is easy to get discouraged and think that what we are doing is not enough.  But, "if we are going to see ourselves as part of that kind of change, we can't use the human life span as a significant standard against which to measure progress," (p. 504).  This is so true.  I like thinking about how as a collective whole we are working towards change that shifts the path toward challenging the values and mind sets that systems of privilege depend on.  I have worked with an organization that helps abused women living with domestic violence.  After seeing my cousin lose her life to domestic violence, I know that the work we are doing is not in vain.  However, there have been times when I wasn't so sure.  With so many women coming in daily, I wondered how we are making a difference.  But then I think about how we are "contribut[ing]to the slow evolution of entire cultures so that forms and values which support privilege begin to lose their 'obvious' legitimacy and normalcy and new forms emerge to challenge their privileged place in social life," (p. 506).  If the work that we are doing provides new pathways for the children and grandchildren of diehard misogynists and abusive men, then I know I am doing the right thing.  And even if it doesn't, I have faith that I am doing the right thing and on the right path.   



Johnson, A.G.  (2012).  What Can We Do?  Becoming Part of the Solution - Reading #52, 6th Edition.

Oliver, M.  (2012).  Disability Definitions: The Politics of Meaning - Reading #18, 6th Edition.

Rochlin, M.  (2012).  The Heterosexual Questionnaire - Reading #17, 6th Edition.


Reflection on Reading #27: Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life by Steven Seidman, Reading #28: Dude, You're a Fag: Adolescent Male Homophobia by C.J. Pascoe, and Reading #29: Sexual Orientation and Sex in Women's Lives: Conceptual and Methodological Issues by Esther D. Rothblum

Reflection on Reading #27: Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life by Steven Seidman, Reading #28: Dude, You're a Fag: Adolescent Male Homophobia by C.J. Pascoe, and Reading #29: Sexual Orientation and Sex in Women's Lives: Conceptual and Methodological Issues by Esther D. Rothblum

The articles listed above examine issues surrounding sexual orientation and how those issues affect the lives and core identities of individuals considered different from mainstream heterosexuality.  Steven Seidman in Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life, reminds us that "...heterosexual dominance is deeply rooted in the institutions and culture of American society," (p. 272).  However, he points out that, historically, homosexuals have not been the targets of state control.  That is until the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries when several powerful groups sought to stop the "spread of vice, divorce, and sexual and gender deviance," (p. 272).  These groups enlisted the state to join in their cause and that's when the state "became heavily involved in regulated the intimate affairs of its citizens," (p. 272).  We see this government involvement today as gay rights advocates are battling states and governments to have marriage equality and gays in the military.  Seidman's point is that today's political agenda for gay rights' advocates has shifted towards not just a tolerance of gays, but a real civil and political equality for gays in our society.  To me, it is unfathomable that there are still some people in our society who object to such basic human rights.  But, nonetheless, here we are.  In order to take a multicultural approach to American ideals, we must make it possible for individuals and marginalized groups to be respected and valued as a real social difference on the political spectrum.  Seidman says, "If an identity or way of life can be deemed worthy of social respect because it promotes personal and social well-being, and cannot be shown to have clear social harm, gays need only make the case that homosexuality is both victimless and, like heterosexuality, essential to personal happiness," (p. 274).  Well said.  Now if we could only start to teach this to our youth.  

In Dude, You're a Fag: Adolescent Male Homophobia, Pascoe discusses what he calls "fag discourse" in American high schools, (p. 281).  He says that "homophobia is central to contemporary definitions of adolescent masculinity," (p. 285).  When you unpack all the different layers and meanings in which the word "fag" is used predominantly among male adolescents, you find that homophobic language is used in a joking manner to assert positions of masculinity.  This is interesting because we probably have all been subjected to a situation in which someone (usually male) is making fun of another male that is considered weaker or more feminine.  When we look at the problem through a different lens, we find that homophobia is more complex than it appears with gendered and racialized meanings.  

My high school was a Catholic all-girls school.  I didn't hear the word "fag" every day but growing up with two brothers, I certainly heard my fair share, unfortunately.  I also experienced people's perceptions of an all-girls school as one in which we all must be lesbians.  I heard that so often that sometimes I did wonder if we were gay and maybe I just didn't  know it.  Looking back, I realize that I grew up in a relatively sheltered environment...one that did not embrace or even talk about differences.  The kids I went to school with were mainly Italian Catholics and any sense of difference was either not addressed or blatantly brushed under the rug.  Sometimes I think it is a wonder that any of us know anything about diversity after growing up under sheltered circumstances and closed-off mind-sets.  Today, knowing that I will encounter adolescents of all different backgrounds, it is my mission not to repeat these same mistakes.  Talking about cultural differences with youth in a meaningful way is the start to encouraging healthy attitudes about peers and other people.  Responding to curiosity of adolescents is not just okay, it is encouraged.  Creating opportunities for students to interact with and make friends with people who are different from them is critical in our multicultural world.  Above all else, it is imperative that we listen to what children are saying and address it accordingly, rather than sweeping these comments under the rug.  

As I was reading these articles, I was reminded of a quote from Mike Rose in his book, Lives on the Boundary.  He says, "Class and culture erect boundaries that hinder our vision - blind us to the logic of error and the everpresent stirring of language - and encourage the designation of otherness, difference, deficiency.  To truly educate in America, to reach the full sweep of our citizenry, we need to question the received perception, shift continually from the standard lens," (Rose, 1989, p. 205).  I think this sums up our mission as educators and as human beings quite poignantly.



Pascoe, C.J.  (2012).  Dude, You're a Fag: Adolescent Male Homophobia - Reading #28, 6th Edition.

Rose, M. (1989). Lives on the boundary. New York, NY: The Free Press.

Rothblum, E.D.  (2012).  Sexual Orientation and Sex in Women's Lives: Conceptual and Methodological Issues - Reading #29, 6th Edition.

Seidman, S.  (2012).  Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life - Reading #27, 6th Edition.

Reflection on Reading #21: Formulating Identity in a Globalized World by Carola Suarez-Orozco, Reading #22: Latinos and the U.S. Race Structure by Clara E. Rodriguez, and Reading #23: Everybody's Ethnic Enigma by Jelita McLeod

Reflection on Reading #21: Formulating Identity in a Globalized World by Carola Suarez-Orozco, Reading #22: Latinos and the U.S. Race Structure by Clara E. Rodriguez, and Reading #23: Everybody's Ethnic Enigma by Jelita McLeod

The above articles talk about how the cultural challenges of globalization affect immigrant youth and how those challenges affect perceptions of identity.  In her article, Formulating Identity in a Globalized World, Suarez-Orozco discusses the ways in which identity is constructed for immigrant youth and suggests that context is an important element.  She states, "Formulating identities that allow individuals to move fluidly from context to context becomes critical to future functioning as global citizens," (p. 229).  Rodriguez in her article, Latinos and the U.S. Race Structure, shares a similar view.  She says, "My personal experiences have suggested to me that for many Latinos, 'racial' classification is immediate, provisional, contextually dependent, and sometimes contested," (p. 237).  This idea is interesting because it shows that race is not just a "given" or "an ascribed characteristic that does not change for anyone, at any time," (p. 237).  Depending on the situation we find ourselves in, the constructs and perceptions of race change.  Jelita McLeod captured this perfectly in her article, Everybody's Ethnic Enigma, when she talks about the encounters she has with total strangers inquiring into her ethnic background.  With each situation, McLeod finds other people imposing certain identities because of what they see in her.  Her point is that we react to the similarities or differences we see in other people.  In fact, she says, "As long as the human eye can detect differences in skin tone, eye shape, hair texture, these differences will play a role in how we interact with one another," (p. 244).  This made me stop and think about how I interact with others, especially others that I see as different as myself.  As a future educator, this is important to analyze within myself.  

Going back to this idea of a globalized world, I asked myself what can I do to bolster my sense of purpose and responsibility to immigrant youth?  Again, as I prepare to teach in the fall, what is my strategy to welcome immigrant youth and provide meaningful education to this group of students.  I believe that it is imperative that we make a concerted effort to place the celebration of cultural differences at the top of our educational agenda.  Creating a sense of community within the classroom that is open and understanding of not just differences but also our similarities is critical in supporting all students.  Tolerance must be fostered among the receiving students as well as the new students coming in.  This can be accomplished by creating an open dialogue among students and their parents.  Including families of students can go a long way in order to foster understanding of one another's cultures.  Allowing newcomers to retain a sense of pride in their home cultures is imperative as we help ease them into their new cultural space.  

I am reminded of a story from my middle school years.  In fifth grade, we received a new student with what we thought was a funny last name.  Turns out he was from the Philippines.  Coming to a primarily Italian-Catholic school, I am sure this individual was anxious to be accepted by us.  I remember my friends making fun of him because he was different in the way he talked and looked.  To this day, I still remember his face when someone turned his last name into a rhyme of less than desired language.  In many ways, I was complicit and went along with my friends.  However, when no one was looking I would try to help him out by explaining certain phrases and their meanings to him.  Looking back I realize that I could have done more but I was too afraid to take a stand or risk losing my friends.  The funny thing is that I barely talk to any of those kids now.  I always wonder what happened to this student.  I also wonder that if maybe our teachers would have had a conversation about cultural differences if things would have been different.  I wonder that if we had been encouraged to have an open dialogue about similarities and differences if this student would have felt more at ease among us.  Who knows?  However, if I am still thinking about this today, I see that this experience really had an impact on me.  As Suarez-Orozco has said, "Preparing our youth to successfully navigate in our multicultural world is essential to preparing them to be global citizens. 
Surely the implications for a more tolerant world are obvious,"  (p. 232).  I wish that would have been as evident when I was in school; however, I know that I will work hard to make sure that my students are prepared to navigate our multicultural world as global citizens.

Suarez-Orozco, C.  (2004).  Formulating Identity in a Globalized World - Reading #21, 6th Edition.      

Rodriguez, C.E.  (2000).  Latinos and the U.S. Race Structure - Reading #22, 6th Edition.

McLeod, J.  (2012).  Everybody's Ethnic Enigma - Reading #23, 6th Edition.


Sunday, July 13, 2014

Reflection on Reading #31: Cause of Death: Inequality by Alejandro Reuss, Reading #32: Why Are Droves of Unqualified, Unprepared Kids Getting into Our Top Colleges? Because Their Dads Are Alumni by John Larew, and Reading #24: It's All in the Family: Intersections of Gender, Race, and Nation by Patricia Hill Collins

Reflection on Reading #31: Cause of Death: Inequality by Alejandro Reuss, Reading #32: Why Are Droves of Unqualified, Unprepared Kids Getting into Our Top Colleges?  Because Their Dads Are Alumni by John Larew, and Reading #24: It's All in the Family: Intersections of Gender, Race, and Nation by Patricia Hill Collins

The three articles above highlight the differences people in separate groups experience. Collins talks about the concept of "family values," popular in the 1990's when Dan Quayle used the term in a political fundraiser speech.  The author contends that the saying proved to be more than just words.  She argues, "the term family values constituted a touchstone, a phrase that apparently tapped much deeper feelings about the significance of ideas of family, if not actual families themselves, in the United States," (p. 245).  She goes on to talk about the "traditional family ideal," perpetuated by conservative groups, as "formed through a combination of marital and blood ties, ideal families consist of heterosexual couples that produce their own biological children," (p. 245).  The structure of authority is specific to the family arrangement and reflects a male-dominated head of household earning a decent wage to support his stay-at-home wife and kids.  Collins delves deeper into the topic by highlighting just how the intersections of race, gender, class, and our nation "mutually construct one another," (p. 246).  By analyzing the dimensions of the traditional family ideal construct, Collins is shedding light on the systems of oppression as well as the "significance of family in shaping social practices," (p. 246).

Collins does a good job of analyzing the dimensions of family and showing that the concept is intertwined with those of race, gender, class, and nation.  I was particularly struck by the significance we attach to biology in definitions of family.  The author states, "In the United States, concepts of family and kinship draw strength from the flow of blood as a substance that regulates the spread of rights," (p. 248).  This made me think about people who do not have that "blood" connection to their family.  I think about my friends who are adopted and have never met their biological parents for a variety of reasons.  And, yet, I know they are still periodically searching for their biological families.  As Collins suggests, this highlights the significance of blood ties in our society.  Another thing that struck me was the author's idea that "despite ideas that social mobility is widespread, U.S. children routinely enjoy or suffer the economic status of their parents," (p. 250).  I'm not sure that I agree with the idea that social mobility is widespread since most of our nation's wealth is concentrated in the top 0.1% of the population; however, I do agree that children often remain in the same socio-economic class as their parents.  This idea brought me to the article by Larew that discusses the overwhelmingly white children of alumni who get into our nation's top colleges simply because they were born into wealth and what the author describes as "handsome lineage," (p. 305).  This article also highlights the the importance of blood ties in our society and visibly shows how these ties work for the privileged few.  

It is interesting to me that the affirmative action debate is back in the news.  The media seems to be up in arms about the practice of affirmative action.  As Larew points out, "Exceptionally high admission rates, lowered admission standards, preferential treatment...hmmm.  These sound like the cries heard in the growing fury over affirmative action for racial minorities in America's elite universities," (p. 306).  And, yet, how interesting that no one says a word about legacies receiving the same preferential treatment.  Even more outrageous is how the social structure of legacies came to be in the first place.  Larew highlights the fact that legacy preference came about in the 1920's when an influx of Jews started to attend elite universities such as Harvard and Yale.  Back then, all that was required was a passing mark on the entrance exam.  Since then, elite schools have instituted non-academic criteria as a way to discriminate against people considered the "other."  In other words, "low-scoring blue bloods" were accepted over their peers on the criteria of "character, solidity, and eventually lineage," according to Larew (p. 307).   This also reflects the sentiment that elite colleges and universities are no longer "truth-seeking" institutions but rather "money-grubbing corporations," (p. 309).  The hypocrisy that runs through these institutions based on legacy preference is astounding.  And while legacy preference is no secret of elite institutions, it is certainly not a central talking point in the national dialogue like affirmative action is....and it should be.  

Lastly, Reuss's article discusses how social inequality is usually the underlying cause of death.  Reuss gives many statistics highlighting the social hierarchy of health.  He says, "In all, the lower you are in a social hierarchy, the worse your health and the shorter your life are likely to be," (p. 302).  Levels of inequality, whether it be income inequality, class inequality, or status inequality, these levels trickle down to affect a person's health.  "Stresses cascade down social hierarchies and accumulate among the least empowered," (Larew, p. 304).  This is incredibly eye-opening and powerful to think about.  Rarely do I think about how social inequalities affect the health of certain groups but now I have a different outlook.  I now have a raised awareness and wonder how I can turn that into action.  

All of the above articles have made me think about social inequality and how it affects every one of us on a daily basis.  From healthcare, to unfair preferences, to outdated ideologies of "family values," I wonder how we can effectively fight against these inequities and injustices.  Sometimes it seems like an uphill battle.  However, if we acknowledge that we are making a difference but that we might not see the fruits of our labor in our lifetime, we can still forge ahead knowing that we tried.


Collins, P.H.  (2013).  It's All in the Family: Intersections of Gender, Race, and Nation - Reading #24, 6th Edition.

Larew, J.  (1991).  Why Are Droves of Unqualified, Unprepared Kids Getting into Our Top Colleges?  Because Their Dads Are Alumni - Reading #32, 6th Edition.


Reuss, A.  (2001). Cause of Death: Inequality- Reading #31, 6th Edition.  

Monday, July 7, 2014

Reflection on Reading #49: Lilly's Big Day by Gail Collins and Reading #50: The Other Movement That Rose Parks Inspired: By Sitting Down, She Made Room for the Disabled by Charles Wilson

Reflection on Reading #49: Lilly's Big Day by Gail Collins, Reading #50: The Other Movement That Rose Parks Inspired: By Sitting Down, She Made Room for the Disabled by Charles Wilson, and Reading #51: Influencing Public Policy by Jeanine C. Cogan

The two articles mentioned above provide inspiring examples of ordinary people coming together to fight for what is right.  Lilly Ledbetter is a retired tire plant supervisor that fought against pay discrimination after finding out how much her male counterparts were making at the Goodyear Tire and Rubber Company.  Despite the fact that a jury found her employer to be extremely guilty of pay discrimination, the Supreme Court, in a bizarre ruling, threw out the case because found that she should have filed her suit within 180 days of the first time Goodyear paid her much less than her colleagues.  Huh?  Such an arbitrary ruling that makes no sense begs the question why.  As the author points out, the 5-to-4 decision in the Supreme Court was led by Bush appointees.  It comes as no surprise then that this "good old boys club" would throw out Lily's case on this minor loophole.  This is maddening.  The author says that Lily is "now part of a long line of working women who went to court and changed a little bit of the world in fights that often brought them minimal personal benefit," (Collins, p. 489).  What does this say about our justice system?  

The author mentions another woman who sued Delta Air Lines in the mid-60's.  Eulalie Cooper, a flight attendant at the time, was fired for being married.  In another bizarre ruling, the Louisiana judge upheld the airline's industry's rules that a flight attendant has to be young and single.  "Cooper was denied unemployment benefits on the grounds that by getting married she left her job 'voluntarily,'" (Collins, p. 489).  This is unbelievable!  Would a man ever lose his job because he wasn't young and single?  Would he ever have to leave his job "voluntarily" because he got married?  Absolutely not.  So why would this apply to women?  The issues of pay discrimination and objectifying women aren't going away any time soon unless we all stand up and fight for what is right.  

It is inspiring to see people motivated and empowered by the actions of Rosa Parks and the entire Civil Rights movement.  As Charles Wilson highlights in his article, we see that disability has no limits when people come together for a specific cause.  "It was through Parks's example that the disabled community transformed its own disorganized cause into a unified disability rights movement," (Wilson, p. 490).  The fact that one person can make a difference is a motivating factor in becoming an activist for important causes such as disability rights.  This article really shed light on the day to day problems that people with disabilities face.  If you can't find suitable transportation and get to work on time, then you run the risk of not being employed.  As Stephanie Thomas points out, "'How could you get a job if you could only get 3 rides a week?  If you were never on time?'" (p. 491).  These are all things that we take for granted sometimes.  When I lived in New York City I never once thought that I wouldn't be able to ride public transportation and, yet, so many people can't due to a lack of wheelchair lifts or broken equipment.  This isn't just something that happened in the 70's and 80's...this is happening now.  Wilson writes, "A 2002 federal Bureau of Transportation Statistics study found that 6 million Americans with disabilities still have trouble obtaining the transportation they need," (p. 492).  This is unfathomable and should definitely not be happening anywhere, much less the United States.  If more policy makers lived with a disability and relied on public transportation to live an independent life, would we see change happening more rapidly?  

We have to ask ourselves what can we do to move change in a meaningful way, especially for those who lack access to basic means of living.  What can we do as individuals to promote a better way of life for all Americans?   Our strength is in our numbers and we have the power to influence public policy.  I found Jeanine C. Cogan's article to be enlightening about the ways we can influence public polity.  She points out that contacting members of Congress and organizing visits with elected officials to discuss relevant issues are just some of the way we can use to promote effective advocacy.  Educating policy making staff helps to increase their knowledge and facts of a particular topic.  Other ways we can advocate for a particular cause are writing a letter to the editor or writing an op-ed column. According to Jeanine C. Cogan, "well-crafted letters to the editor and op-ed columns can raise awareness of the issues locally, regionally, and nationally," (p. 501).  This is good advice and something that we all can participate in.  

Cogan, J.C. (2003). Influencing Public Policy- Reading #51, 6th Edition.  

Collins, G.  (2009).  Lily's Big Day - Reading #49, 6th Edition.    

Wilson, C.  (2005).  The Other Movement That Rose Parks Inspired: By Sitting Down, She Made Room for the Disabled - Reading #50, 6th Edition.

Friday, June 27, 2014

Reflection on Reading #38: Between Barack and a Hard Place by Tim Wise and Reading #36: Blink in Black and White by Malcolm Gladwell

Reflection on Reading #38: Between Barack and a Hard Place by Tim Wise and Reading #36: Blink in Black and White by Malcolm Gladwell

In his compelling article, Between Barack and a Hard Place, Wise reminds us that racism is by no means obsolete in our country even with the presidential win of Barack Obama.  Wise (2013) says that "...given the evidence regarding entrenched racial inequities in employment, education, health care, criminal justice, housing and elsewhere - and the studies indicating these are due in large measure to discrimination, either past, present, or a combination of the two - it most definitely does not suggest that racism has been truncated as an ongoing social problem for persons of color generally," (p. 364).  He goes on to say that we have developed in our culture two types of racism.  The first, or "Racism 1.0," as Wise calls it, is the overt bigotry and discrimination displayed by the white dominant culture.  That old-fashioned "racial bonding" against communities of color was set aside during the election for bigger interests such as economics.  Speaking of the white voters, Wise states, "    Even if they harbored ongoing prejudices toward African Americans generally (and evidence suggests that many still did), they were prepared to vote their pocketbooks and break with a long tradition, stretching back decades...," (p. 364).  This, Wise believes, is not to be confused with the newer "2.0 Racism" that Wise describes as an idea "in which whites hold the larger black community in low regard and here, for instance, to any number of racist stereotypes about African Americans - and yet carve out acceptable space for individuals such as Obama who strike them as different, as exceptions who are not like the rest," (p. 365).  This "enlightened exceptionalism" Wise contends is alive and well today in America.   

I agree with Wise that racism in this country is still going on despite the momentous achievements of not only Barack Obama, but of people of color everywhere.  I also agree that white people have tended to ignore the issue of race on a national level so it is not surprising that they would declare the struggle of racism over as soon as an African American was elected president.  Although I believe we should celebrate any incremental progress we make on this front, I do believe that the systematic oppression we have created in this country is not going away any time soon unless we all take a stand.  I believe that our power is in our plurality and even though we have unconscious attitudes and implicit biases, as Malcolm Gladwell points out in his article, Blink in Black and White, I think that we can combat these by raising awareness and having a true national dialogue about the issue of racism.  One that is not constructed or constrained by the narrow-mindedness of the media.

I was fascinated with the ideas put forth in Gladwell's article about our implicit and unconscious biases measured in the IAT or Implicit Association test.  After taking the test (https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/), I was blown away by my own unconscious attitudes and how those attitudes differed from my stated values.  Gladwell (2007) points out, "The disturbing thing about the test is that it shows that our unconscious attitudes may be utterly incompatible with our stated conscious values," (p. 355).  It's like even when we consciously choose the right path and attitudes, our unconsciousness can get the better of us as we are inundated with cultural messages telling us white is good.  It is interesting that we unconsciously form opinions that we otherwise would not have anything to do with.  I think we always need to be aware of this as every spontaneous situation has the potential to filter our pro-white associations through.  Although I was rated on the Race IAT has having a "moderate automatic preference for whites," I will definitely be more aware of my attitudes and biases as I move forward in life.  I think this is important to teach our children as well as they are our future.

Gladwell, M. (2007). Blink in Black and White- Reading #36, 6th Edition.  

Wise, T.  (2013).  Between Barack and a Hard Place - Reading #38, 6th Edition.

Monday, June 23, 2014

Reflection on Reading #33 and #34: The True Meaning of Disability

Reflection on Reading #33: Public Transit by John Hockenberry and Reading #34: "Can You See the Rainbow?"  The Roots of Denial by Sally French and Reading #35: Not Blind Enough: Living in the Borderland Called Legal Blindness by Beth Omansky

The articles by John Hockenberry and Sally French really made me ponder the preconceived notions that I have about people with disabilities.  I found their articles to be informative and enlightening about the meaning of disability.  More specifically, their articles made me think about how being "different" affects people's lives.  How can we learn from their experiences and commonalities?  And how can we challenge and change these constructions of difference?  I'm not sure I have any answers but I believe it is important to keep this dialogue open and moving forward.  

We are all shaped by our life experiences.  Recognizing the impact our experiences have on our life is not always easy to understand.  As I was reading the two articles mentioned above, I was reminded of my own experience living in New York City before moving to Vermont.  I thought about how many times I was one of those commuters who stepped around someone in a wheelchair or completely ignored someone who might have needed help using public transit.  I thought about all the times I saw someone of color being passed up by a cab driver only to pull up to a white person a block away.  Theses were every day occurrences.  I see now that these experiences have had an impact on my life.  At the time, I saw the injustice of these situations but I just thought, well, that's how life works.  "The mass transit system[s] that are inaccessible to wheelchair users 'disable' them by making it difficult or impossible to work, attend school, or manage basic sociability," (Rosenblum & Travis, 2012, p. 6).  How could I possibly make a difference in the lives of these individuals?  Today I realize that my inaction and blatant ignorance of people with disabilities has made a difference in the lives of these individuals.  Hockenberry says, "...I hadn't counted on being completely ignored," (p. 316).  And, yet, how many times have I seen this happen?  Too many to count.  That makes me incredibly sad and ashamed that I have perpetuated this kind of behavior.  Isn't it ironic that New York City has millions of people living on top of each other and, yet, it can be one of the most isolating and lonely places out there.  I can only imagine how someone bound by cultural stereotypes and disabling environments must feel.  

The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (2007) reflects the idea that "disability should be seen as the result of the interaction between a person and his or her environment.  Disability is not something that resides in the individual as the result of some impairment...Disability resides in the society, not in the person," (p. 6).  This definition extended my thinking about disability and its social constructions and categorizations.  In Sally French's article, I was particularly struck by how her interactions with adults really shaped how she viewed and denied her disability.  She says, "By denying the reality of my disability I protected myself from the anxiety, disapproval, frustration and disappointment of the adults in my life," (p. 318).  This whole idea that she highlights that "the behavior of the adults clearly conveyed the message, 'You are not acceptable as you are,'" (p. 319) is heartbreaking and unimaginable to think about, especially for children.  And, yet, we see children in our classrooms desperately seeking approval and acceptance from their peers and adults by denying who they are and the reality of their situations.  For example, I worked with a student who was seen as different by his peers and adults because he had Tourette Syndrome.  He would often interject humor in between his involuntary facial and vocal tics.  Humor had become his way of "dealing with his situation."  However, upon reflection, it seems like this was a coping mechanism for this child, a way to adapt and be "normal."  As French puts it, "This behavior signals two distinct messages: first that I have failed to be 'normal' (and have therefore failed), and second that I must ask for nothing more," (p. 322).  This quote is powerful and  shows the challenges that people with disability face on a daily basis.  I wonder what it means to be "normal."  If we are to celebrate our differences and uniqueness, then nothing and no one can be seen as "normal."  I agree with French that "genuine structural and attitudinal change" are needed in order to give the support and encouragement to make the needs known of people with disabilities.  

The underlying message of these two articles that we should never deny someone's disability or enable that disability to hide who they are is a powerful one.  It is a message that sheds light on the negative stigma of disability.  The message reminds us that this whole idea of "normal" is a fallacy in our society that only promotes this image of the "other" who is not at all like "us."  As Rosenblum and Travis put it, "Whether in race, sex, sexual orientation, social class, or disability, dichotomization yields a vision of 'them' as profoundly different.  Ultimately, dichotomization results in stigmatizing those who are less powerful.  It provides the grounds for whole categories of people to become the objects of contempt," (p. 31).  It is time to change this mindset so that we can begin to bridge our differences.


French, S.  (2008).  "Can You See the Rainbow?"  The Roots of Denial - Reading #34, 6th Edition.      

Hockenberry, J.  (1996).  Public Transit- Reading #33, 6th Edition. 

Omansky, B.  (2006).  Not Blind Enough: Living in the Borderland Called Legal Blindness- Reading #35, 6th Edition. 

Rosenblum, K.E. & Travis, T.M.  (2012).  The meaning of difference.  New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.  

Friday, June 20, 2014

Reflection on Reading #45: Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America by Diana Kendall and Reading #46: Loot or Find: Fact or Frame? by Cheryl I. Harris & Devon W. Carbado

Reflection on Reading #45: Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America by Diana Kendall and Reading #46: Loot or Find: Fact or Frame? by Cheryl I. Harris & Devon W. Carbado

Kendall's article highlights the problems of media framing and the impact it has on our every day lives in terms of class, race, and gender. Kendall says, "Rather than providing a meaningful analysis of inequality and showing realistic portrayals of life in various social classes, the media either play class differences for laughs or sweep the issue of class under the rug so that important distinctions are rendered invisible," (p. 448). I thought this observation was rather powerful in light of all the "reality" television that is readily available to view these days. I never thought about how certain shows in the media pit one class against another and this reading really made me ponder that division. For example, I grew up watching The Simpsons and yet I never thought about its portrayal of the working class through what the author calls "caricature framing," (p. 451). Kendall explains that caricature framing "depicts people in negative ways, such as being dumb, white trash, buffoons, bigots, or slobs," (p. 451). While it is true that Homer Simpson, for example, is portrayed as a slob and a buffoon, I never thought about why " situation comedy writers have perpetuated working-class stereotypes," (p. 451). However, it is clear that such depictions, however harmless we think they are, do represent a negative view of people in lower socio-economic classes.  As a society, our perceptions of social class are greatly influenced by the media. When the media misrepresents social class, it is our society as a whole that pays the price.

Kendall's article extended my thinking about the concept of framing.  Kendall argues that the media rarely discuss class explicitly, but their portrayals of the classes generate perceptions that influence behavior.  She illustrates this argument by identifying class-based frames (i.e., representations of the classes).  The upper class is generally framed positively in the media: they are composed of everyday individuals who are generous and caring and should be emulated.  Even when members of the upper class are framed in a negative light, the media illustrates that upper class criminals have remarkably good lives.  We saw this highlighted through the media's coverage of the financial/banking crisis in 2008.  Not one executive in the banking industry has been brought to justice thus far.  I wonder what is going on here?  We also saw this in the media's framing of the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina.  Someone of color wading through chest deep water with a bag of supplies was considered a looter but the white people doing the exact same thing were "surviving," (p. 454).  As Harris and Carbado point out, "so much of public opinion is grounded in misinformation," (p. 455).  We interpret the "facts" based on our prior experiences and our frames of reference.  Therefore, we see the "facts" as we want to see them and possibly not as they are.  This article was eye-opening for me in terms of how our perceptions of the facts are shaped.  "...Katrina offers profound insights into how race operates in American society, insights into how various facts about our social life are racially interpreted through frames," (p. 459).  

Like the poor, the working class and working poor are often ignored in the media.  The working class' relative invisibility results because they are frequently mislabeled as part of the middle class.  This seems to impede efforts to develop class awareness because members of the working class typically self-identify as middle class, and this misconception is reinforced in the media. When the working class is visible, diverse frames emerge.  The final class discussed in the article is the middle class.  Kendall argues that the middle class was historically framed in terms of values, but this frame has increasingly been replaced by negative representations where the middle class is losing its security and standard of living because it is victimized by multiple groups in society, including politicians and criminals.
Kendall argues that media depictions of the classes ignore societal and structural determinants of class positions, causes that are heavily emphasized in the sociological literature.  For example, depictions of the upper class ignore economic inequities that generate upper class standing.  Likewise, the media rarely consider macro-level causes of impoverishment, such as educational opportunity or underemployment due to economic shifts.  This finding certainly points to a need for sociologists to better publicize their research results, making journalists and the public more aware of class-based inequities and structural determinants of these inequities.


Kendall, D. (2011). Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America- Reading #45, 6th Edition.


Harris, C.I. & Carbado, D.W.  (2010).  Loot or Find: Fact or Frame? - Reading #46, 6th Edition.

Monday, June 16, 2014

Reflection on Reading 12: What's Class Got to Do with It? by Michael Zweig and Reading #13: More or Less Equal? The Economist

Reflection on Reading #12: What's Class Got to Do with It? by Michael Zweig and Reading #13: More or Less Equal by The Economist

Michael Zweig's article, What's Class Got to Do with It?, is the author's examination of class as a central marker in our every day lives.  Much like race and gender, class helps to shape our lives as well as our identity.  Zweig explores class analysis and the understanding of class structure as a way to demonstrate the defining factor of class: power.  The working class, Zweig says, is composed of people who have "little power or authority" at work or in our society, (p. 130).  As capitalism has emerged triumphant after the Cold War and as capitalists are asserting their power more brazenly in the United States and abroad, the issues related to class have been thrust into the spotlight making the central importance of class increasingly obvious for everyone to see.    

As I was reading Michael Zweig's article, What's Class Got to Do with It?, two quotes stood out to me.  The first is "[...class can be better understood] as mainly a question of economic and political power," (p. 130).  The second is "Power exists as a relationship between and among different people or groups," (p. 130).  These statements stand out because they highlight some of the challenges we face in the 21st century.  When we see chief executives paying themselves tens of millions of dollars while their employees are thrown out of work and denied public services, we have to wonder if we are all in this together.  When working class people see huge tax cuts going to the wealthiest 1% of our population while their tiny tax relief is eaten up by the financial crisis, we have to find a common ground to begin to talk about these issues related to class in our society.  The one thing that mitigates the powerlessness that working class people feel is our plurality.  Zweig says, "in the United States, working class people are by far the majority of the population.  Over eighty-eight million people were in working class occupations in 2002, comprising 62 percent of the labor force," (p. 131).  Conversely, Zweig points out that capitalists comprise only 2 percent of the U.S. labor force.  That's a huge difference.  It tells us that we need to engage and unify the dormant power of our plurality.  In order to do this we must understand class in terms of power rather than income, wealth, or lifestyle, although it is true that these do vary by class.  Using powers as the starting point allows us to see class as a dynamic relationship rather than a static set of characteristics.    

It seems as though the real source with political and economic misdirection in this country is the increasingly unbridled power of the capitalist class and their arrogant pursuit of profit for the few at the expense of the vast majority of Americans and peoples of the world. This should be the target of our politics. Being rich is not the key point. Conservatives have convinced too many Americans that their problems stem from government coddling the poor. We need to redirect this anger, not towards “the rich” but towards the corporate elite. Such an approach could not be twisted into “threats to rob working people of their future.” Hopefully, through a national discourse on the subject of class and power, we can begin to solve the problems associated with it.

Zweig, M. (2004).  What's Class Got to Do with It? - Reading #12, 6th Edition.

The Economist.  (2009).  More or Less Equal? - Reading #13, 6th Edition.


Thursday, June 12, 2014

Reflection on Reading #53: In Defense of Rich Kids by William Upski Wimsatt and Reading #54: Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice by Paul Kivel

Reflection on Reading #53: In Defense of Rich Kids by William Upski Wimsatt and Reading #54: Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice by Paul Kivel

In his article, In Defense of Rich Kids, William Wimsatt reminds us that people are all different and that goes for people with money too.  He points out that he is the beneficiary of an unfair system that gives him "tons of free money for doing nothing, yet it forces you to work two and three jobs just to get out of debt," (p. 508). His message is clear that we all need to work together in order to change the political landscape of this country.  Changing the political landscape will help to change the unfair systems we have in place that reward the rich and damage the middle class and poor.  Wimsatt says that it is more effective for people with money to give to organizing efforts that have little or no financial support rather than to organizations that support bureaucratic institutions that "maintain system problems by treating the symptoms and obscuring root causes," (p. 508).  His vision of creating a new kind of organization that will establish new fields of work for social change is risky, but that's the challenge he is willing to take on.  He asks that other privileged people with money join him in this effort.  He asks that we, as a society, talk about what it means to have money and how we can effectively put that money to good use, rather than not talking about it at all.    

Like many people, I have always tried my best to be open and accepting to everyone.  However, before I read this article, I have to admit that I had a preconceived notion of this "rich kid."  I thought that because he doesn't have to work, he doesn't know what it is like for the rest of us who have to work for a living. However, I had a much different outlook after reading his piece.  And it goes back to the idea that we shouldn't judge a book by its cover.  It is great to see people who are socioeconomically privileged giving back to our society.  I imagine there are more people like him and, accordingly, we shouldn't judge them based on our preconceived notions of what we think all rich people are like.  That only perpetuates the cycle of in equality and the idea that all people lumped into the same category are alike, no matter their merits.

In Paul Kivel's article, the author talks about what we can do to work for racial justice.  He tells us to take risks, speak up, support, listen and make mistakes.  He says, "every situation is different and calls for critical thinking about how to make a difference," (p. 514).  This is a good message because every situation is set in a different context and we need to be aware of that in order to generate change or to make a difference.  I believe we need to take risks and speak up when we see racism, especially in our classrooms.  Teaching our children about racism and that it is good to talk about, rather than avoid it, is critical if we want to change the status quo and our current political system.  I know I will work to make these changes in myself and in my children.  In order to embrace diversity, we need to work together to build support and establish networks.  The issue of racism and discrimination is not going away unless we make it a priority and work together to change it.

Wimsatt, W.U. (1999).  In Defense of Rich Kids - Reading #53, 6th Edition.

Kivel, P.  (2011).  Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice - Reading #54, 6th Edition.

Reflection on Reading 4: Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America by Marie Garroutte and Reading 2: Who is Black? One Nation's Definition by F. James Davis

Reflection on Reading 4: Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America by Marie Garroutte and Reading 2: Who is Black?  One Nation's Definition by F. James Davis

Garroutte explores the identity of Native Americans through their citizenship rights and requirements as defined by U.S. law as well as those of specific tribes.  It is interesting, but not surprising, that the requirements of each tribe vary from the legal definitions put into place by the U.S. Congress.  Garroutte highlights, "Because of these wide variations in legal identity definitions and their frequent departure from the various tribal ones, many individuals who are recognized by their tribes as citizens are nevertheless considered non-Indian for some or all federal purposes," (p. 67).   Garroutte does a good job of documenting how these requirements have been manipulated by the federal government, by trial officials, and by Indian and non-Indian individuals to gain political, social, or economic advantage.

After reading this article and the article on "Who is Black?  One Nation's Definition" by F. James Davis, I am struck and perplexed by all these arbitrary rules that we have to determine a person's racial and ethnic identity.  It is crazy to me that we are still using antiquated systems and definitions to determine a person's ancestry.  Davis points out, "Not only does the one-drop rule apply to no other group than American blacks, but apparently the rule is unique in that it is found in the United States and not in any other nation in the world," (p. 62).  This is appalling to me.  And it makes me wonder what makes me "white"?  As far as I know, I pass the one-drop rule test and yet I have never been identified as anything other than white or Caucasian.  It is interesting because a genetic test might show something else entirely so what's "correct?"  Does social pressure dictate this?  

This entire discussion on race is interesting and uncomfortable at times.  However, I believe it is something that we should be addressing in our schools with our students.  I wonder how many Americans realize how we define certain groups, like Native Americans and Black Americans.  As Davis points out, "Most Americans seem unaware that this definition of blacks is extremely unusual in other countries, perhaps even unique to the United States, and that Americans define no other minority group in a similar way..." (p. 63).  How can this still be in the 21st century?  How can we find a way to talk about this with others in a way that is productive when the concepts underlying biological definitions of identity are so far from common sense, as Garroutte reminds us (p. 69)?     

Garroutte, M.  (2012).  Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America - Reading #4, 6th Edition.

 Davis, F.J.  (2012).  Who is Black?  One Nation's Definition - Reading #2, 6th Edition.

Monday, June 9, 2014

Reflection on Reading 1: "Race" and the Construction of Human Identity by Audrey Smedley

Reflection on Reading 1: "Race" and the Construction of Human Identity by Audrey Smedley

As I was reading Audrey Smedley's article about the historical and social constructions of identity, I thought about the following quote by the Roman orator Cicero, "History...provides guidance in daily life, and brings us tidings of antiquity," (Samovar, 2012, p. 40).  I believe Cicero was correct that all cultures believe in the idea that history provides stories about the past that serve as lessons on how to live in the present.  History highlights the culture's origins, "tells" its members what is deemed important, and identifies the accomplishments of the culture of which they can be proud.  However, sometimes history has not been so kind to certain human identities based on external physical features and the imposed social meaning of those physical features.  Smedley's article is a fascinating look into the modern conceptions of race and human identity.  She points out that people of the ancient world understood that ethnic identity itself was dynamic and changeable.  Smedley (1998) says, "Populations did not necessarily lose any form of ethnic identity, but change was clearly understood as virtually inevitable as each society learned something new from the cultures of others...," (p. 46).  This is a fascinating point since it seems as though we look at identity today as something that is unmalleable and constant.  It is striking that biological differences among human groups were not given meaning in the ancient world because today biological differences pervade the concept of human identity as markers of social status.

I agree with Smedley and most scholars today that "race is nothing more and nothing less than a social invention," (p. 53).  In fact, race has nothing to do with the superficial physical differences upon which is was imposed and everything to do with power, privilege, and wealth - who has it and who does not.  Once we begin to understand the real nature of race as a social construct can we begin to deal with the implications that racial and ethnic identities have imposed on various groups of people.  As we have seen throughout history, ethical standards vary from culture to culture and are subject to change.  As we shift towards a more globalized world, perhaps, our standards and norms will converge and lead to common values regarding our understanding of human identity.  I like the idea of "universal" human beings.  I believe this idea will help us move forward in recognizing identity as fluid and multicultural.     

It is interesting to see how the concept of race has emerged throughout history.  As such, it makes me think about how conceptions could be different if historical events followed a different path.  I believe Shannon brought this up in class and I thought it was a fascinating idea: what if the colonial revolt known as Bacon's Rebellion in 1676 had succeeded?  Would we have different ways of looking at racial ideology and the arbitrary rankings of people associated with it?  I wonder...

Smedley, A. (1998).  "Race" and the Construction of Human Identity - Reading #1, 6th Edition


Samovar, L., Porter, R.E. and McDaniel, E.R. (2013).  Communication between cultures, 8Ed.  Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing.

Saturday, June 7, 2014

Reflection on Reading 9: The Gendered Society by Michael S. Kimmel and Reading 10: Where's the Rulebook for Sex Verification? by Alice Dreger

Reflection on Reading 9: The Gendered Society by Michael S. Kimmel and Reading 10: Where's the Rulebook for Sex Verification?  by Alice Dreger

In his article, The Gendered Society, Michael S. Kimmel discusses the study of gender.  Why is it that society has categorized women and men as  practically two different species?  Kimmel points out that women and men are far more alike than they are different.  We co-exist in a world where we are constantly reminded that gender difference also equates to gender inequality and that inequality is universal.  As Kimmel suggests, "when we speak about gender we also speak about hierarchy, power, and inequality, not simply difference," (p. 114).  This is interesting because not only is gender inequality found in virtually every known society but, according to Kimmel, each of these societies are male dominated.  Why is that?  And why is every society built upon the perceived differences between men and women?  This got me thinking about how men and women are socialized in society.  As Kimmel says, "we are not necessarily born different; we become different through this process of socialization," (p. 115).  But what about those individuals who are born with both male and female anatomies, or what Alice Dreger terms "intersex" individuals?  How are these individuals socialized?  What strikes me is that gender and sex typing are both complicated issues with many layers of meaning.  As we peel back these layers of meaning, we can start to make sense of how to approach these issues as we move forward in society.  Generating awareness is the first step in adequately addressing these issues in our culture.

The idea that Kimmel asserts that "by eliminating gender inequality, we will remove the foundation upon which the entire edifice of gender difference is built," (p. 116) is an interesting one.  However, it also makes me wonder how we can achieve the elimination of gender inequality.  I like Kimmel's idea that as gender inequality decreases, the differences among people will emerge as qualities to be appreciated and celebrated along with our commonality, (p. 116).  Again, how can we achieve this end?  Kimmel reminds us that we can start by making gender visible for both men and women.  Gender is just one way that we can make sense of our experiences and social constructions and it joins race and class in our understandings of an individual's identity.  It is interesting to see that since the 1970's gender has been thought of as a woman's issue in terms of feminism.  However, there seem to be no courses that address the issues of men and masculinity.  As Kimmel states, "so we continue to act as if gender applied only to women," (p. 117).  This point struck me because we tend to think of our society as a male dominated one.  

Kimmel goes on to say that, perhaps, the differences we see between men and women in every day life are not actually gender differences but rather the result of being in different positions in different arenas.  Studies have shown that gender matters far less than opportunity.  "When women had the same opportunities, networks, mentors, and possibilities for advancement, they behaved just as men did," (p. 120).  This is interesting because it brings me back to Dreger's article.  How are intersex people taught to socialize.  When they have the same opportunities as men and women, society deems them to have a competitive advantage, according to Dreger.  Take, for instance, the case of Caster Semenya, the world-champion runner from South Africa whose sex is being investigated by field and track's governing body.  Dreger raises a good point by asking where do we craw the line between men and women in athletic competitions?  You can see more in her Ted Talk about this issue.  The issue of intersex individuals is fascinating because it is not a black and white issue and is very complex.  I never really thought about it until I read Dreger's article and then watched her Ted Talk.  I believe it is something that we need to address as a society as we move forward with our discussion of diversity issues.

Alice Dreger's Ted Talk: 
http://www.ted.com/talks/alice_dreger_is_anatomy_destiny

Dreger, A.  (2009).  Where's the Rulebook for Sex Verification? - Reading #10, 6th Edition

Kimmel, M.S.  (2000).  The Gendered Society - Reading #9, 6th Edition
  

Thursday, June 5, 2014

Reflection on Reading 8: From Friendly Foreigner to Enemy Race by John Tehranian

Reflection on Reading 8: From Friendly Foreigner to Enemy Race by John Tehranian

It wasn't until the 1850's when the term "Middle East" emerged.  Born out of geopolitical considerations, the term "Middle East" referred to a strategic region designated rich in oil.   According to Tehranian, the relatively recent construct of this term appears not as the typical regional definition based on a shared continent and language or perceived ethnic boundaries, but rather as an area of interest to the United States and Britain (p. 104).  The fact that the term "Middle East" encompasses many regions that are subject to change proves Tehranian's point that this region is a relative newcomer to the geopolitical world stage.  After reading Tehranian's article, I was particularly struck by how stereotypes and the racialization of certain cultures change over time depending on society's needs.  The fact that Middle Easterners were once viewed as "friendly" foreigners in the eyes of most Americans but are no longer today viewed that way demonstrates that stereotypes and depictions of certain cultures depend on society's needs.  History has shown us several examples of certain cultures typecast and discriminated against.  Take, for example, antiblack prejudice which sprang up with slavery.  Richard Delgado reminds us that "previously, educated Europeans held generally positive attitudes toward Africans, recognizing the African civilization was highly advanced," (p. 105).  Similarly, the rising occurrence of discrimination facing persons of Middle Eastern descent has been socially constructed to fit our post 9/11 view that Middle Easterners are "foreign, Arab terrorists" (Romero, p. 106).  Tehranian states, "It is hardly a coincidence that it has occurred over the past generation--a time that has seen the Middle East rise to the forefront of global politics and economic importance due to its ample reserves of the great engine of industrialization: oil," (p. 105). 

I was particularly struck by Tehranian's point that socio-cultural perceptions of race are inextricably tied to religion.  He points out that, contrary to popular belief, only 23% of Arab Americans today are actually Muslim.  As cultural perceptions of a particular group become increasingly seen as " the Other," so do perceptions of whether or not these people can be assimilated into our vision of society.  Tehranian says, "the past century has witnessed a radical transformation in majority perceptions of Middle Eastern individuals: they are, in short, no longer thought capable of assimilation," (p. 106).   Therefore, the identity of Middle Easterners has come under assault and they are seen, by a majority of Americans, as an enemy race.  This is interesting because according to census information, Middle Easterners are technically considered white.  I wonder how many Americans even know this or care, for that matter.   This got me thinking about James A. Banks' article on human rights and, although Article 1 of the UDHR states that "All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.  They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act toward one another in a spirit of brotherhood," (p. 100), it is clear that this is not what we actually practice.  Banks goes on to state that "immigrants were taught hope and shame" and only when they became culturally assimilated were they given hope for structural inclusion into American society, (p. 101).  Up until that point, immigrants were taught to be ashamed of their languages, cultures, and families.  For Middle Easterners in the United States today, the notion of assimilation seems like a remote possibility.  This contradicts Banks' idea that "structural inclusion, cultural empowerment, equality, and recognition are essential conditions for the internalization of human rights values, attitudes, and behaviors," (p. 101-102).  

In modern democratic societies, I wonder if assimilation is the right path for any ethnic group.  Multicultural citizenship seems much more open to the right and need for people to maintain ties with their cultural communities as well as to the nation state in which they are legal citizens.  I agree with Banks that "global education should have as major goals helping students to develop understandings of the interdependence among nations in the world today, clarified attitudes toward other nations, and reflective identifications with the world community," (p. 106).  This should be the goal of all schools so that students could form a clearer and deeper understanding of the need to take action and make decisions that will enhance democracy and promote social justice, not just in their community but in the world abroad.  I believe that if I had been taught the tenets of multicultural citizenship when I was in school, I would have had a much different outlook on those that I considered the "Other" when I was growing up.  I believe these ideas are just as relevant today as our culture is so divided politically and socially.  Perhaps, if we begin to teach students about multicultural citizenship we will be able to change their preconceived notions of other cultural groups, such as Middle Easterners, especially in this post 9/11 era.  

Banks, James A. “Human Rights, Diversity, and Citizenship Education”

Tehranian, J.  (2008).  From Friendly Foreigner to Enemy Race - Reading #8, 6th Edition