Reflection on Reading #31: Cause of Death: Inequality by Alejandro Reuss, Reading #32: Why Are Droves of Unqualified, Unprepared Kids Getting into Our Top Colleges? Because Their Dads Are Alumni by John Larew, and Reading #24: It's All in the Family: Intersections of Gender, Race, and Nation by Patricia Hill Collins
The three articles above highlight the differences people in separate groups experience. Collins talks about the concept of "family values," popular in the 1990's when Dan Quayle used the term in a political fundraiser speech. The author contends that the saying proved to be more than just words. She argues, "the term family values constituted a touchstone, a phrase that apparently tapped much deeper feelings about the significance of ideas of family, if not actual families themselves, in the United States," (p. 245). She goes on to talk about the "traditional family ideal," perpetuated by conservative groups, as "formed through a combination of marital and blood ties, ideal families consist of heterosexual couples that produce their own biological children," (p. 245). The structure of authority is specific to the family arrangement and reflects a male-dominated head of household earning a decent wage to support his stay-at-home wife and kids. Collins delves deeper into the topic by highlighting just how the intersections of race, gender, class, and our nation "mutually construct one another," (p. 246). By analyzing the dimensions of the traditional family ideal construct, Collins is shedding light on the systems of oppression as well as the "significance of family in shaping social practices," (p. 246).
Collins does a good job of analyzing the dimensions of family and showing that the concept is intertwined with those of race, gender, class, and nation. I was particularly struck by the significance we attach to biology in definitions of family. The author states, "In the United States, concepts of family and kinship draw strength from the flow of blood as a substance that regulates the spread of rights," (p. 248). This made me think about people who do not have that "blood" connection to their family. I think about my friends who are adopted and have never met their biological parents for a variety of reasons. And, yet, I know they are still periodically searching for their biological families. As Collins suggests, this highlights the significance of blood ties in our society. Another thing that struck me was the author's idea that "despite ideas that social mobility is widespread, U.S. children routinely enjoy or suffer the economic status of their parents," (p. 250). I'm not sure that I agree with the idea that social mobility is widespread since most of our nation's wealth is concentrated in the top 0.1% of the population; however, I do agree that children often remain in the same socio-economic class as their parents. This idea brought me to the article by Larew that discusses the overwhelmingly white children of alumni who get into our nation's top colleges simply because they were born into wealth and what the author describes as "handsome lineage," (p. 305). This article also highlights the the importance of blood ties in our society and visibly shows how these ties work for the privileged few.
It is interesting to me that the affirmative action debate is back in the news. The media seems to be up in arms about the practice of affirmative action. As Larew points out, "Exceptionally high admission rates, lowered admission standards, preferential treatment...hmmm. These sound like the cries heard in the growing fury over affirmative action for racial minorities in America's elite universities," (p. 306). And, yet, how interesting that no one says a word about legacies receiving the same preferential treatment. Even more outrageous is how the social structure of legacies came to be in the first place. Larew highlights the fact that legacy preference came about in the 1920's when an influx of Jews started to attend elite universities such as Harvard and Yale. Back then, all that was required was a passing mark on the entrance exam. Since then, elite schools have instituted non-academic criteria as a way to discriminate against people considered the "other." In other words, "low-scoring blue bloods" were accepted over their peers on the criteria of "character, solidity, and eventually lineage," according to Larew (p. 307). This also reflects the sentiment that elite colleges and universities are no longer "truth-seeking" institutions but rather "money-grubbing corporations," (p. 309). The hypocrisy that runs through these institutions based on legacy preference is astounding. And while legacy preference is no secret of elite institutions, it is certainly not a central talking point in the national dialogue like affirmative action is....and it should be.
Lastly, Reuss's article discusses how social inequality is usually the underlying cause of death. Reuss gives many statistics highlighting the social hierarchy of health. He says, "In all, the lower you are in a social hierarchy, the worse your health and the shorter your life are likely to be," (p. 302). Levels of inequality, whether it be income inequality, class inequality, or status inequality, these levels trickle down to affect a person's health. "Stresses cascade down social hierarchies and accumulate among the least empowered," (Larew, p. 304). This is incredibly eye-opening and powerful to think about. Rarely do I think about how social inequalities affect the health of certain groups but now I have a different outlook. I now have a raised awareness and wonder how I can turn that into action.
All of the above articles have made me think about social inequality and how it affects every one of us on a daily basis. From healthcare, to unfair preferences, to outdated ideologies of "family values," I wonder how we can effectively fight against these inequities and injustices. Sometimes it seems like an uphill battle. However, if we acknowledge that we are making a difference but that we might not see the fruits of our labor in our lifetime, we can still forge ahead knowing that we tried.
Collins, P.H. (2013). It's All in the Family: Intersections of Gender, Race, and Nation - Reading #24, 6th Edition.
Larew, J. (1991). Why Are Droves of Unqualified, Unprepared Kids Getting into Our Top Colleges? Because Their Dads Are Alumni - Reading #32, 6th Edition.
Reuss, A. (2001). Cause of Death: Inequality- Reading #31, 6th Edition.
No comments:
Post a Comment