Monday, July 14, 2014

Reflection on Reading #27: Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life by Steven Seidman, Reading #28: Dude, You're a Fag: Adolescent Male Homophobia by C.J. Pascoe, and Reading #29: Sexual Orientation and Sex in Women's Lives: Conceptual and Methodological Issues by Esther D. Rothblum

Reflection on Reading #27: Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life by Steven Seidman, Reading #28: Dude, You're a Fag: Adolescent Male Homophobia by C.J. Pascoe, and Reading #29: Sexual Orientation and Sex in Women's Lives: Conceptual and Methodological Issues by Esther D. Rothblum

The articles listed above examine issues surrounding sexual orientation and how those issues affect the lives and core identities of individuals considered different from mainstream heterosexuality.  Steven Seidman in Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life, reminds us that "...heterosexual dominance is deeply rooted in the institutions and culture of American society," (p. 272).  However, he points out that, historically, homosexuals have not been the targets of state control.  That is until the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries when several powerful groups sought to stop the "spread of vice, divorce, and sexual and gender deviance," (p. 272).  These groups enlisted the state to join in their cause and that's when the state "became heavily involved in regulated the intimate affairs of its citizens," (p. 272).  We see this government involvement today as gay rights advocates are battling states and governments to have marriage equality and gays in the military.  Seidman's point is that today's political agenda for gay rights' advocates has shifted towards not just a tolerance of gays, but a real civil and political equality for gays in our society.  To me, it is unfathomable that there are still some people in our society who object to such basic human rights.  But, nonetheless, here we are.  In order to take a multicultural approach to American ideals, we must make it possible for individuals and marginalized groups to be respected and valued as a real social difference on the political spectrum.  Seidman says, "If an identity or way of life can be deemed worthy of social respect because it promotes personal and social well-being, and cannot be shown to have clear social harm, gays need only make the case that homosexuality is both victimless and, like heterosexuality, essential to personal happiness," (p. 274).  Well said.  Now if we could only start to teach this to our youth.  

In Dude, You're a Fag: Adolescent Male Homophobia, Pascoe discusses what he calls "fag discourse" in American high schools, (p. 281).  He says that "homophobia is central to contemporary definitions of adolescent masculinity," (p. 285).  When you unpack all the different layers and meanings in which the word "fag" is used predominantly among male adolescents, you find that homophobic language is used in a joking manner to assert positions of masculinity.  This is interesting because we probably have all been subjected to a situation in which someone (usually male) is making fun of another male that is considered weaker or more feminine.  When we look at the problem through a different lens, we find that homophobia is more complex than it appears with gendered and racialized meanings.  

My high school was a Catholic all-girls school.  I didn't hear the word "fag" every day but growing up with two brothers, I certainly heard my fair share, unfortunately.  I also experienced people's perceptions of an all-girls school as one in which we all must be lesbians.  I heard that so often that sometimes I did wonder if we were gay and maybe I just didn't  know it.  Looking back, I realize that I grew up in a relatively sheltered environment...one that did not embrace or even talk about differences.  The kids I went to school with were mainly Italian Catholics and any sense of difference was either not addressed or blatantly brushed under the rug.  Sometimes I think it is a wonder that any of us know anything about diversity after growing up under sheltered circumstances and closed-off mind-sets.  Today, knowing that I will encounter adolescents of all different backgrounds, it is my mission not to repeat these same mistakes.  Talking about cultural differences with youth in a meaningful way is the start to encouraging healthy attitudes about peers and other people.  Responding to curiosity of adolescents is not just okay, it is encouraged.  Creating opportunities for students to interact with and make friends with people who are different from them is critical in our multicultural world.  Above all else, it is imperative that we listen to what children are saying and address it accordingly, rather than sweeping these comments under the rug.  

As I was reading these articles, I was reminded of a quote from Mike Rose in his book, Lives on the Boundary.  He says, "Class and culture erect boundaries that hinder our vision - blind us to the logic of error and the everpresent stirring of language - and encourage the designation of otherness, difference, deficiency.  To truly educate in America, to reach the full sweep of our citizenry, we need to question the received perception, shift continually from the standard lens," (Rose, 1989, p. 205).  I think this sums up our mission as educators and as human beings quite poignantly.



Pascoe, C.J.  (2012).  Dude, You're a Fag: Adolescent Male Homophobia - Reading #28, 6th Edition.

Rose, M. (1989). Lives on the boundary. New York, NY: The Free Press.

Rothblum, E.D.  (2012).  Sexual Orientation and Sex in Women's Lives: Conceptual and Methodological Issues - Reading #29, 6th Edition.

Seidman, S.  (2012).  Beyond the Closet: The Transformation of Gay and Lesbian Life - Reading #27, 6th Edition.

No comments:

Post a Comment