As I was reading Audrey Smedley's article about the historical and social constructions of identity, I thought about the following quote by the Roman orator Cicero, "History...provides guidance in daily life, and brings us tidings of antiquity," (Samovar, 2012, p. 40). I believe Cicero was correct that all cultures believe in the idea that history provides stories about the past that serve as lessons on how to live in the present. History highlights the culture's origins, "tells" its members what is deemed important, and identifies the accomplishments of the culture of which they can be proud. However, sometimes history has not been so kind to certain human identities based on external physical features and the imposed social meaning of those physical features. Smedley's article is a fascinating look into the modern conceptions of race and human identity. She points out that people of the ancient world understood that ethnic identity itself was dynamic and changeable. Smedley (1998) says, "Populations did not necessarily lose any form of ethnic identity, but change was clearly understood as virtually inevitable as each society learned something new from the cultures of others...," (p. 46). This is a fascinating point since it seems as though we look at identity today as something that is unmalleable and constant. It is striking that biological differences among human groups were not given meaning in the ancient world because today biological differences pervade the concept of human identity as markers of social status.
I agree with Smedley and most scholars today that "race is nothing more and nothing less than a social invention," (p. 53). In fact, race has nothing to do with the superficial physical differences upon which is was imposed and everything to do with power, privilege, and wealth - who has it and who does not. Once we begin to understand the real nature of race as a social construct can we begin to deal with the implications that racial and ethnic identities have imposed on various groups of people. As we have seen throughout history, ethical standards vary from culture to culture and are subject to change. As we shift towards a more globalized world, perhaps, our standards and norms will converge and lead to common values regarding our understanding of human identity. I like the idea of "universal" human beings. I believe this idea will help us move forward in recognizing identity as fluid and multicultural.
It is interesting to see how the concept of race has emerged throughout history. As such, it makes me think about how conceptions could be different if historical events followed a different path. I believe Shannon brought this up in class and I thought it was a fascinating idea: what if the colonial revolt known as Bacon's Rebellion in 1676 had succeeded? Would we have different ways of looking at racial ideology and the arbitrary rankings of people associated with it? I wonder...
Smedley, A. (1998). "Race" and the Construction of Human Identity - Reading #1, 6th Edition
Samovar,
L., Porter, R.E. and McDaniel, E.R. (2013).
Communication between cultures,
8Ed.
Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing.
No comments:
Post a Comment