Friday, June 20, 2014

Reflection on Reading #45: Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America by Diana Kendall and Reading #46: Loot or Find: Fact or Frame? by Cheryl I. Harris & Devon W. Carbado

Reflection on Reading #45: Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America by Diana Kendall and Reading #46: Loot or Find: Fact or Frame? by Cheryl I. Harris & Devon W. Carbado

Kendall's article highlights the problems of media framing and the impact it has on our every day lives in terms of class, race, and gender. Kendall says, "Rather than providing a meaningful analysis of inequality and showing realistic portrayals of life in various social classes, the media either play class differences for laughs or sweep the issue of class under the rug so that important distinctions are rendered invisible," (p. 448). I thought this observation was rather powerful in light of all the "reality" television that is readily available to view these days. I never thought about how certain shows in the media pit one class against another and this reading really made me ponder that division. For example, I grew up watching The Simpsons and yet I never thought about its portrayal of the working class through what the author calls "caricature framing," (p. 451). Kendall explains that caricature framing "depicts people in negative ways, such as being dumb, white trash, buffoons, bigots, or slobs," (p. 451). While it is true that Homer Simpson, for example, is portrayed as a slob and a buffoon, I never thought about why " situation comedy writers have perpetuated working-class stereotypes," (p. 451). However, it is clear that such depictions, however harmless we think they are, do represent a negative view of people in lower socio-economic classes.  As a society, our perceptions of social class are greatly influenced by the media. When the media misrepresents social class, it is our society as a whole that pays the price.

Kendall's article extended my thinking about the concept of framing.  Kendall argues that the media rarely discuss class explicitly, but their portrayals of the classes generate perceptions that influence behavior.  She illustrates this argument by identifying class-based frames (i.e., representations of the classes).  The upper class is generally framed positively in the media: they are composed of everyday individuals who are generous and caring and should be emulated.  Even when members of the upper class are framed in a negative light, the media illustrates that upper class criminals have remarkably good lives.  We saw this highlighted through the media's coverage of the financial/banking crisis in 2008.  Not one executive in the banking industry has been brought to justice thus far.  I wonder what is going on here?  We also saw this in the media's framing of the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina.  Someone of color wading through chest deep water with a bag of supplies was considered a looter but the white people doing the exact same thing were "surviving," (p. 454).  As Harris and Carbado point out, "so much of public opinion is grounded in misinformation," (p. 455).  We interpret the "facts" based on our prior experiences and our frames of reference.  Therefore, we see the "facts" as we want to see them and possibly not as they are.  This article was eye-opening for me in terms of how our perceptions of the facts are shaped.  "...Katrina offers profound insights into how race operates in American society, insights into how various facts about our social life are racially interpreted through frames," (p. 459).  

Like the poor, the working class and working poor are often ignored in the media.  The working class' relative invisibility results because they are frequently mislabeled as part of the middle class.  This seems to impede efforts to develop class awareness because members of the working class typically self-identify as middle class, and this misconception is reinforced in the media. When the working class is visible, diverse frames emerge.  The final class discussed in the article is the middle class.  Kendall argues that the middle class was historically framed in terms of values, but this frame has increasingly been replaced by negative representations where the middle class is losing its security and standard of living because it is victimized by multiple groups in society, including politicians and criminals.
Kendall argues that media depictions of the classes ignore societal and structural determinants of class positions, causes that are heavily emphasized in the sociological literature.  For example, depictions of the upper class ignore economic inequities that generate upper class standing.  Likewise, the media rarely consider macro-level causes of impoverishment, such as educational opportunity or underemployment due to economic shifts.  This finding certainly points to a need for sociologists to better publicize their research results, making journalists and the public more aware of class-based inequities and structural determinants of these inequities.


Kendall, D. (2011). Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America- Reading #45, 6th Edition.


Harris, C.I. & Carbado, D.W.  (2010).  Loot or Find: Fact or Frame? - Reading #46, 6th Edition.

No comments:

Post a Comment