Reflection on Reading 4: Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America by Marie Garroutte and Reading 2: Who is Black? One Nation's Definition by F. James Davis
Garroutte explores the identity of Native Americans through their citizenship rights and requirements as defined by U.S. law as well as those of specific tribes. It is interesting, but not surprising, that the requirements of each tribe vary from the legal definitions put into place by the U.S. Congress. Garroutte highlights, "Because of these wide variations in legal identity definitions and their frequent departure from the various tribal ones, many individuals who are recognized by their tribes as citizens are nevertheless considered non-Indian for some or all federal purposes," (p. 67). Garroutte does a good job of documenting how these requirements have been manipulated by the federal government, by trial officials, and by Indian and non-Indian individuals to gain political, social, or economic advantage.
After reading this article and the article on "Who is Black? One Nation's Definition" by F. James Davis, I am struck and perplexed by all these arbitrary rules that we have to determine a person's racial and ethnic identity. It is crazy to me that we are still using antiquated systems and definitions to determine a person's ancestry. Davis points out, "Not only does the one-drop rule apply to no other group than American blacks, but apparently the rule is unique in that it is found in the United States and not in any other nation in the world," (p. 62). This is appalling to me. And it makes me wonder what makes me "white"? As far as I know, I pass the one-drop rule test and yet I have never been identified as anything other than white or Caucasian. It is interesting because a genetic test might show something else entirely so what's "correct?" Does social pressure dictate this?
This entire discussion on race is interesting and uncomfortable at times. However, I believe it is something that we should be addressing in our schools with our students. I wonder how many Americans realize how we define certain groups, like Native Americans and Black Americans. As Davis points out, "Most Americans seem unaware that this definition of blacks is extremely unusual in other countries, perhaps even unique to the United States, and that Americans define no other minority group in a similar way..." (p. 63). How can this still be in the 21st century? How can we find a way to talk about this with others in a way that is productive when the concepts underlying biological definitions of identity are so far from common sense, as Garroutte reminds us (p. 69)?
Garroutte, M. (2012). Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America - Reading #4, 6th Edition.
Davis, F.J. (2012). Who is Black? One Nation's Definition - Reading #2, 6th Edition.
No comments:
Post a Comment