Reflection on Reading #12: What's Class Got to Do with
It? by Michael Zweig and Reading #13: More or Less Equal by The Economist
Michael
Zweig's article, What's Class Got to Do with It?, is the author's
examination of class as a central marker in our every day lives. Much
like race and gender, class helps to shape our lives as well as our identity.
Zweig explores class analysis and the understanding of class structure as
a way to demonstrate the defining factor of class: power. The working class,
Zweig says, is composed of people who have "little power or
authority" at work or in our society, (p. 130). As capitalism has
emerged triumphant after the Cold War and as capitalists are asserting their
power more brazenly in the United States and abroad, the issues related to
class have been thrust into the spotlight making the central importance of
class increasingly obvious for everyone to see.
As I was
reading Michael Zweig's article, What's Class Got to Do with It?,
two quotes stood out to me. The first is "[...class can be better
understood] as mainly a question of economic and political power," (p.
130). The second is "Power exists as a relationship between and
among different people or groups," (p. 130). These statements stand
out because they highlight some of the challenges we face in the 21st century.
When we see chief executives paying themselves tens of millions of
dollars while their employees are thrown out of work and denied public
services, we have to wonder if we are all in this together. When working
class people see huge tax cuts going to the wealthiest 1% of our population
while their tiny tax relief is eaten up by the financial crisis, we have to
find a common ground to begin to talk about these issues related to class in
our society. The one thing that mitigates the powerlessness that working
class people feel is our plurality. Zweig says, "in the United
States, working class people are by far the majority of the population.
Over eighty-eight million people were in working class occupations in
2002, comprising 62 percent of the labor force," (p. 131).
Conversely, Zweig points out that capitalists comprise only 2 percent of
the U.S. labor force. That's a huge difference. It tells us that we
need to engage and unify the dormant power of our plurality. In order to
do this we must understand class in terms of power rather than income, wealth,
or lifestyle, although it is true that these do vary by class. Using
powers as the starting point allows us to see class as a dynamic relationship
rather than a static set of characteristics.
It seems
as though the real source with political and economic misdirection in this
country is the increasingly unbridled power of the capitalist class and their
arrogant pursuit of profit for the few at the expense of the vast majority of
Americans and peoples of the world. This should be the target of our politics.
Being rich is not the key point. Conservatives have convinced too many
Americans that their problems stem from government coddling the poor. We need
to redirect this anger, not towards “the rich” but towards the corporate elite.
Such an approach could not be twisted into “threats to rob working people of
their future.” Hopefully, through a national discourse on the subject of class
and power, we can begin to solve the problems associated with it.
Zweig, M. (2004). What's Class Got to Do
with It? - Reading #12, 6th Edition.
The Economist. (2009). More or Less Equal? - Reading #13, 6th Edition.
The Economist. (2009). More or Less Equal? - Reading #13, 6th Edition.
Jen,
ReplyDeleteI think your most important statement is, “we need to engage and unify the dormant power of our plurality.” Imagine if every single person in the working class voted in the next election! It’s like another Doctor Suess book, Horton Hears a Who. Separately we are weak, together we are powerful; once we reach critical mass, we could take over! Now if we could just get enough people in office who are there to meet our agenda instead of their own… Thanks, Claudia