Thursday, June 5, 2014

Reflection on Reading 8: From Friendly Foreigner to Enemy Race by John Tehranian

Reflection on Reading 8: From Friendly Foreigner to Enemy Race by John Tehranian

It wasn't until the 1850's when the term "Middle East" emerged.  Born out of geopolitical considerations, the term "Middle East" referred to a strategic region designated rich in oil.   According to Tehranian, the relatively recent construct of this term appears not as the typical regional definition based on a shared continent and language or perceived ethnic boundaries, but rather as an area of interest to the United States and Britain (p. 104).  The fact that the term "Middle East" encompasses many regions that are subject to change proves Tehranian's point that this region is a relative newcomer to the geopolitical world stage.  After reading Tehranian's article, I was particularly struck by how stereotypes and the racialization of certain cultures change over time depending on society's needs.  The fact that Middle Easterners were once viewed as "friendly" foreigners in the eyes of most Americans but are no longer today viewed that way demonstrates that stereotypes and depictions of certain cultures depend on society's needs.  History has shown us several examples of certain cultures typecast and discriminated against.  Take, for example, antiblack prejudice which sprang up with slavery.  Richard Delgado reminds us that "previously, educated Europeans held generally positive attitudes toward Africans, recognizing the African civilization was highly advanced," (p. 105).  Similarly, the rising occurrence of discrimination facing persons of Middle Eastern descent has been socially constructed to fit our post 9/11 view that Middle Easterners are "foreign, Arab terrorists" (Romero, p. 106).  Tehranian states, "It is hardly a coincidence that it has occurred over the past generation--a time that has seen the Middle East rise to the forefront of global politics and economic importance due to its ample reserves of the great engine of industrialization: oil," (p. 105). 

I was particularly struck by Tehranian's point that socio-cultural perceptions of race are inextricably tied to religion.  He points out that, contrary to popular belief, only 23% of Arab Americans today are actually Muslim.  As cultural perceptions of a particular group become increasingly seen as " the Other," so do perceptions of whether or not these people can be assimilated into our vision of society.  Tehranian says, "the past century has witnessed a radical transformation in majority perceptions of Middle Eastern individuals: they are, in short, no longer thought capable of assimilation," (p. 106).   Therefore, the identity of Middle Easterners has come under assault and they are seen, by a majority of Americans, as an enemy race.  This is interesting because according to census information, Middle Easterners are technically considered white.  I wonder how many Americans even know this or care, for that matter.   This got me thinking about James A. Banks' article on human rights and, although Article 1 of the UDHR states that "All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.  They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act toward one another in a spirit of brotherhood," (p. 100), it is clear that this is not what we actually practice.  Banks goes on to state that "immigrants were taught hope and shame" and only when they became culturally assimilated were they given hope for structural inclusion into American society, (p. 101).  Up until that point, immigrants were taught to be ashamed of their languages, cultures, and families.  For Middle Easterners in the United States today, the notion of assimilation seems like a remote possibility.  This contradicts Banks' idea that "structural inclusion, cultural empowerment, equality, and recognition are essential conditions for the internalization of human rights values, attitudes, and behaviors," (p. 101-102).  

In modern democratic societies, I wonder if assimilation is the right path for any ethnic group.  Multicultural citizenship seems much more open to the right and need for people to maintain ties with their cultural communities as well as to the nation state in which they are legal citizens.  I agree with Banks that "global education should have as major goals helping students to develop understandings of the interdependence among nations in the world today, clarified attitudes toward other nations, and reflective identifications with the world community," (p. 106).  This should be the goal of all schools so that students could form a clearer and deeper understanding of the need to take action and make decisions that will enhance democracy and promote social justice, not just in their community but in the world abroad.  I believe that if I had been taught the tenets of multicultural citizenship when I was in school, I would have had a much different outlook on those that I considered the "Other" when I was growing up.  I believe these ideas are just as relevant today as our culture is so divided politically and socially.  Perhaps, if we begin to teach students about multicultural citizenship we will be able to change their preconceived notions of other cultural groups, such as Middle Easterners, especially in this post 9/11 era.  

Banks, James A. “Human Rights, Diversity, and Citizenship Education”

Tehranian, J.  (2008).  From Friendly Foreigner to Enemy Race - Reading #8, 6th Edition

1 comment:

  1. Hi Jen,
    I agree that we need to teach students to be global citizens. Allowing people to maintain ties to their cultural communities as well as the nation state in which they live gives them a broader view of the world. If people are able to keep their identities of who they are, not who their nation state wants them to be, then they are able to view the world very differently. I think this also empowers them to embrace the differences in other people. I think in order to solve the problems in the world today, global warming, food crisis, disease, etc, it will require a diverse group of people working together. I am wondering if teaching global citizenship will help change preconceived notions. Students are still influenced by parents, friends, and the media.

    ReplyDelete