Saturday, June 7, 2014

Reflection on Reading 9: The Gendered Society by Michael S. Kimmel and Reading 10: Where's the Rulebook for Sex Verification? by Alice Dreger

Reflection on Reading 9: The Gendered Society by Michael S. Kimmel and Reading 10: Where's the Rulebook for Sex Verification?  by Alice Dreger

In his article, The Gendered Society, Michael S. Kimmel discusses the study of gender.  Why is it that society has categorized women and men as  practically two different species?  Kimmel points out that women and men are far more alike than they are different.  We co-exist in a world where we are constantly reminded that gender difference also equates to gender inequality and that inequality is universal.  As Kimmel suggests, "when we speak about gender we also speak about hierarchy, power, and inequality, not simply difference," (p. 114).  This is interesting because not only is gender inequality found in virtually every known society but, according to Kimmel, each of these societies are male dominated.  Why is that?  And why is every society built upon the perceived differences between men and women?  This got me thinking about how men and women are socialized in society.  As Kimmel says, "we are not necessarily born different; we become different through this process of socialization," (p. 115).  But what about those individuals who are born with both male and female anatomies, or what Alice Dreger terms "intersex" individuals?  How are these individuals socialized?  What strikes me is that gender and sex typing are both complicated issues with many layers of meaning.  As we peel back these layers of meaning, we can start to make sense of how to approach these issues as we move forward in society.  Generating awareness is the first step in adequately addressing these issues in our culture.

The idea that Kimmel asserts that "by eliminating gender inequality, we will remove the foundation upon which the entire edifice of gender difference is built," (p. 116) is an interesting one.  However, it also makes me wonder how we can achieve the elimination of gender inequality.  I like Kimmel's idea that as gender inequality decreases, the differences among people will emerge as qualities to be appreciated and celebrated along with our commonality, (p. 116).  Again, how can we achieve this end?  Kimmel reminds us that we can start by making gender visible for both men and women.  Gender is just one way that we can make sense of our experiences and social constructions and it joins race and class in our understandings of an individual's identity.  It is interesting to see that since the 1970's gender has been thought of as a woman's issue in terms of feminism.  However, there seem to be no courses that address the issues of men and masculinity.  As Kimmel states, "so we continue to act as if gender applied only to women," (p. 117).  This point struck me because we tend to think of our society as a male dominated one.  

Kimmel goes on to say that, perhaps, the differences we see between men and women in every day life are not actually gender differences but rather the result of being in different positions in different arenas.  Studies have shown that gender matters far less than opportunity.  "When women had the same opportunities, networks, mentors, and possibilities for advancement, they behaved just as men did," (p. 120).  This is interesting because it brings me back to Dreger's article.  How are intersex people taught to socialize.  When they have the same opportunities as men and women, society deems them to have a competitive advantage, according to Dreger.  Take, for instance, the case of Caster Semenya, the world-champion runner from South Africa whose sex is being investigated by field and track's governing body.  Dreger raises a good point by asking where do we craw the line between men and women in athletic competitions?  You can see more in her Ted Talk about this issue.  The issue of intersex individuals is fascinating because it is not a black and white issue and is very complex.  I never really thought about it until I read Dreger's article and then watched her Ted Talk.  I believe it is something that we need to address as a society as we move forward with our discussion of diversity issues.

Alice Dreger's Ted Talk: 
http://www.ted.com/talks/alice_dreger_is_anatomy_destiny

Dreger, A.  (2009).  Where's the Rulebook for Sex Verification? - Reading #10, 6th Edition

Kimmel, M.S.  (2000).  The Gendered Society - Reading #9, 6th Edition
  

2 comments:

  1. Hi Jen,
    I think the whole discussion of gender is multifaceted. One of the articles I read recently said that male domination has only been around for about seven thousand years. I think this was in reading 52. The point to the article was that human beings have been around for hundreds of thousands of years. So it was a slow evolution that promoted male dominance. So I guess that point is that we can change gender inequalities, we just may not see those changes in our lifetime. Our society may seem like a male dominate one, but all the things we doing to change that will be seen in future generations. I wonder what society will look like in 100 years. Will we still have gender inequalities? What about people born as intersex?
    I think of the woman you wrote about from South Africa, Caster Semenya. Who gets to decide if she is male or female? I feel bad that she was sideline and required to take a test. Since we categories people, she has chosen to be female. I do not think anyone else has the right to tell her otherwise, or make her do anything else. Is there going to be a new category in the future, intersex? Or will we change the way we view gender?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Jen,
    While reading your response as well as Pam's comment about intersex possibly becoming a new category in the future, I began to think about my student teaching experience at a high school. Male and female bathrooms presented many problems for a small group of students (that may be increasing in the future) that felt uncomfortable in the specified male and female categories. My cooperating teacher expressed her concerns and felt that the issue needed to be addressed, but until the school is remodeled she felt like the issue remained on the back burner. I think that we need to address the current needs of students in the school and since the categories of male and female are inadequate, changes in the way that we view gender remain necessary.

    ReplyDelete