Reflection on Reading #38: Between Barack and a Hard Place by Tim Wise and Reading #36: Blink in Black and White by Malcolm Gladwell
In his compelling article, Between Barack and a Hard Place, Wise reminds us that racism is by no means obsolete in our country even with the presidential win of Barack Obama. Wise (2013) says that "...given the evidence regarding entrenched racial inequities in employment, education, health care, criminal justice, housing and elsewhere - and the studies indicating these are due in large measure to discrimination, either past, present, or a combination of the two - it most definitely does not suggest that racism has been truncated as an ongoing social problem for persons of color generally," (p. 364). He goes on to say that we have developed in our culture two types of racism. The first, or "Racism 1.0," as Wise calls it, is the overt bigotry and discrimination displayed by the white dominant culture. That old-fashioned "racial bonding" against communities of color was set aside during the election for bigger interests such as economics. Speaking of the white voters, Wise states, " Even if they harbored ongoing prejudices toward African Americans generally (and evidence suggests that many still did), they were prepared to vote their pocketbooks and break with a long tradition, stretching back decades...," (p. 364). This, Wise believes, is not to be confused with the newer "2.0 Racism" that Wise describes as an idea "in which whites hold the larger black community in low regard and here, for instance, to any number of racist stereotypes about African Americans - and yet carve out acceptable space for individuals such as Obama who strike them as different, as exceptions who are not like the rest," (p. 365). This "enlightened exceptionalism" Wise contends is alive and well today in America.
I agree with Wise that racism in this country is still going on despite the momentous achievements of not only Barack Obama, but of people of color everywhere. I also agree that white people have tended to ignore the issue of race on a national level so it is not surprising that they would declare the struggle of racism over as soon as an African American was elected president. Although I believe we should celebrate any incremental progress we make on this front, I do believe that the systematic oppression we have created in this country is not going away any time soon unless we all take a stand. I believe that our power is in our plurality and even though we have unconscious attitudes and implicit biases, as Malcolm Gladwell points out in his article, Blink in Black and White, I think that we can combat these by raising awareness and having a true national dialogue about the issue of racism. One that is not constructed or constrained by the narrow-mindedness of the media.
I was fascinated with the ideas put forth in Gladwell's article about our implicit and unconscious biases measured in the IAT or Implicit Association test. After taking the test (https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/), I was blown away by my own unconscious attitudes and how those attitudes differed from my stated values. Gladwell (2007) points out, "The disturbing thing about the test is that it shows that our unconscious attitudes may be utterly incompatible with our stated conscious values," (p. 355). It's like even when we consciously choose the right path and attitudes, our unconsciousness can get the better of us as we are inundated with cultural messages telling us white is good. It is interesting that we unconsciously form opinions that we otherwise would not have anything to do with. I think we always need to be aware of this as every spontaneous situation has the potential to filter our pro-white associations through. Although I was rated on the Race IAT has having a "moderate automatic preference for whites," I will definitely be more aware of my attitudes and biases as I move forward in life. I think this is important to teach our children as well as they are our future.
Gladwell, M. (2007). Blink in Black and White- Reading #36, 6th Edition.
Wise, T. (2013). Between Barack and a Hard Place - Reading #38, 6th Edition.
No comments:
Post a Comment