Thursday, June 12, 2014

Reflection on Reading #53: In Defense of Rich Kids by William Upski Wimsatt and Reading #54: Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice by Paul Kivel

Reflection on Reading #53: In Defense of Rich Kids by William Upski Wimsatt and Reading #54: Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice by Paul Kivel

In his article, In Defense of Rich Kids, William Wimsatt reminds us that people are all different and that goes for people with money too.  He points out that he is the beneficiary of an unfair system that gives him "tons of free money for doing nothing, yet it forces you to work two and three jobs just to get out of debt," (p. 508). His message is clear that we all need to work together in order to change the political landscape of this country.  Changing the political landscape will help to change the unfair systems we have in place that reward the rich and damage the middle class and poor.  Wimsatt says that it is more effective for people with money to give to organizing efforts that have little or no financial support rather than to organizations that support bureaucratic institutions that "maintain system problems by treating the symptoms and obscuring root causes," (p. 508).  His vision of creating a new kind of organization that will establish new fields of work for social change is risky, but that's the challenge he is willing to take on.  He asks that other privileged people with money join him in this effort.  He asks that we, as a society, talk about what it means to have money and how we can effectively put that money to good use, rather than not talking about it at all.    

Like many people, I have always tried my best to be open and accepting to everyone.  However, before I read this article, I have to admit that I had a preconceived notion of this "rich kid."  I thought that because he doesn't have to work, he doesn't know what it is like for the rest of us who have to work for a living. However, I had a much different outlook after reading his piece.  And it goes back to the idea that we shouldn't judge a book by its cover.  It is great to see people who are socioeconomically privileged giving back to our society.  I imagine there are more people like him and, accordingly, we shouldn't judge them based on our preconceived notions of what we think all rich people are like.  That only perpetuates the cycle of in equality and the idea that all people lumped into the same category are alike, no matter their merits.

In Paul Kivel's article, the author talks about what we can do to work for racial justice.  He tells us to take risks, speak up, support, listen and make mistakes.  He says, "every situation is different and calls for critical thinking about how to make a difference," (p. 514).  This is a good message because every situation is set in a different context and we need to be aware of that in order to generate change or to make a difference.  I believe we need to take risks and speak up when we see racism, especially in our classrooms.  Teaching our children about racism and that it is good to talk about, rather than avoid it, is critical if we want to change the status quo and our current political system.  I know I will work to make these changes in myself and in my children.  In order to embrace diversity, we need to work together to build support and establish networks.  The issue of racism and discrimination is not going away unless we make it a priority and work together to change it.

Wimsatt, W.U. (1999).  In Defense of Rich Kids - Reading #53, 6th Edition.

Kivel, P.  (2011).  Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice - Reading #54, 6th Edition.

No comments:

Post a Comment