Reflection on Reading #33: Public Transit by John Hockenberry and Reading #34: "Can You See the Rainbow?" The Roots of Denial by Sally French and Reading #35: Not Blind Enough: Living in the Borderland Called Legal Blindness by Beth Omansky
The articles by John Hockenberry and Sally French really made me ponder the preconceived notions that I have about people with disabilities. I found their articles to be informative and enlightening about the meaning of disability. More specifically, their articles made me think about how being "different" affects people's lives. How can we learn from their experiences and commonalities? And how can we challenge and change these constructions of difference? I'm not sure I have any answers but I believe it is important to keep this dialogue open and moving forward.
We are all shaped by our life experiences. Recognizing the impact our experiences have on our life is not always easy to understand. As I was reading the two articles mentioned above, I was reminded of my own experience living in New York City before moving to Vermont. I thought about how many times I was one of those commuters who stepped around someone in a wheelchair or completely ignored someone who might have needed help using public transit. I thought about all the times I saw someone of color being passed up by a cab driver only to pull up to a white person a block away. Theses were every day occurrences. I see now that these experiences have had an impact on my life. At the time, I saw the injustice of these situations but I just thought, well, that's how life works. "The mass transit system[s] that are inaccessible to wheelchair users 'disable' them by making it difficult or impossible to work, attend school, or manage basic sociability," (Rosenblum & Travis, 2012, p. 6). How could I possibly make a difference in the lives of these individuals? Today I realize that my inaction and blatant ignorance of people with disabilities has made a difference in the lives of these individuals. Hockenberry says, "...I hadn't counted on being completely ignored," (p. 316). And, yet, how many times have I seen this happen? Too many to count. That makes me incredibly sad and ashamed that I have perpetuated this kind of behavior. Isn't it ironic that New York City has millions of people living on top of each other and, yet, it can be one of the most isolating and lonely places out there. I can only imagine how someone bound by cultural stereotypes and disabling environments must feel.
The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (2007) reflects the idea that "disability should be seen as the result of the interaction between a person and his or her environment. Disability is not something that resides in the individual as the result of some impairment...Disability resides in the society, not in the person," (p. 6). This definition extended my thinking about disability and its social constructions and categorizations. In Sally French's article, I was particularly struck by how her interactions with adults really shaped how she viewed and denied her disability. She says, "By denying the reality of my disability I protected myself from the anxiety, disapproval, frustration and disappointment of the adults in my life," (p. 318). This whole idea that she highlights that "the behavior of the adults clearly conveyed the message, 'You are not acceptable as you are,'" (p. 319) is heartbreaking and unimaginable to think about, especially for children. And, yet, we see children in our classrooms desperately seeking approval and acceptance from their peers and adults by denying who they are and the reality of their situations. For example, I worked with a student who was seen as different by his peers and adults because he had Tourette Syndrome. He would often interject humor in between his involuntary facial and vocal tics. Humor had become his way of "dealing with his situation." However, upon reflection, it seems like this was a coping mechanism for this child, a way to adapt and be "normal." As French puts it, "This behavior signals two distinct messages: first that I have failed to be 'normal' (and have therefore failed), and second that I must ask for nothing more," (p. 322). This quote is powerful and shows the challenges that people with disability face on a daily basis. I wonder what it means to be "normal." If we are to celebrate our differences and uniqueness, then nothing and no one can be seen as "normal." I agree with French that "genuine structural and attitudinal change" are needed in order to give the support and encouragement to make the needs known of people with disabilities.
The underlying message of these two articles that we should never deny someone's disability or enable that disability to hide who they are is a powerful one. It is a message that sheds light on the negative stigma of disability. The message reminds us that this whole idea of "normal" is a fallacy in our society that only promotes this image of the "other" who is not at all like "us." As Rosenblum and Travis put it, "Whether in race, sex, sexual orientation, social class, or disability, dichotomization yields a vision of 'them' as profoundly different. Ultimately, dichotomization results in stigmatizing those who are less powerful. It provides the grounds for whole categories of people to become the objects of contempt," (p. 31). It is time to change this mindset so that we can begin to bridge our differences.
French, S. (2008). "Can You See the Rainbow?" The Roots of Denial - Reading #34, 6th Edition.
Hockenberry, J. (1996). Public Transit- Reading #33, 6th Edition.
Omansky, B. (2006). Not Blind Enough: Living in the Borderland Called Legal Blindness- Reading #35, 6th Edition.
Rosenblum, K.E. & Travis, T.M. (2012). The meaning of difference. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
I agree with everything you wrote Jen. As a child I felt sorry for people with visible disabilities. I didn't know anyone with a disability until I met a boy with diabetes. This was in the 1960's and before I was diagnosed with the same disease. I felt sorry for him that he had to take shots and eat different foods than the rest of us. Then I suddenly had the same thing several years later while in my teens.
ReplyDelete