Reflection on Reading #38: Between Barack and a Hard Place by Tim Wise and Reading #36: Blink in Black and White by Malcolm Gladwell
In his compelling article, Between Barack and a Hard Place, Wise reminds us that racism is by no means obsolete in our country even with the presidential win of Barack Obama. Wise (2013) says that "...given the evidence regarding entrenched racial inequities in employment, education, health care, criminal justice, housing and elsewhere - and the studies indicating these are due in large measure to discrimination, either past, present, or a combination of the two - it most definitely does not suggest that racism has been truncated as an ongoing social problem for persons of color generally," (p. 364). He goes on to say that we have developed in our culture two types of racism. The first, or "Racism 1.0," as Wise calls it, is the overt bigotry and discrimination displayed by the white dominant culture. That old-fashioned "racial bonding" against communities of color was set aside during the election for bigger interests such as economics. Speaking of the white voters, Wise states, " Even if they harbored ongoing prejudices toward African Americans generally (and evidence suggests that many still did), they were prepared to vote their pocketbooks and break with a long tradition, stretching back decades...," (p. 364). This, Wise believes, is not to be confused with the newer "2.0 Racism" that Wise describes as an idea "in which whites hold the larger black community in low regard and here, for instance, to any number of racist stereotypes about African Americans - and yet carve out acceptable space for individuals such as Obama who strike them as different, as exceptions who are not like the rest," (p. 365). This "enlightened exceptionalism" Wise contends is alive and well today in America.
I agree with Wise that racism in this country is still going on despite the momentous achievements of not only Barack Obama, but of people of color everywhere. I also agree that white people have tended to ignore the issue of race on a national level so it is not surprising that they would declare the struggle of racism over as soon as an African American was elected president. Although I believe we should celebrate any incremental progress we make on this front, I do believe that the systematic oppression we have created in this country is not going away any time soon unless we all take a stand. I believe that our power is in our plurality and even though we have unconscious attitudes and implicit biases, as Malcolm Gladwell points out in his article, Blink in Black and White, I think that we can combat these by raising awareness and having a true national dialogue about the issue of racism. One that is not constructed or constrained by the narrow-mindedness of the media.
I was fascinated with the ideas put forth in Gladwell's article about our implicit and unconscious biases measured in the IAT or Implicit Association test. After taking the test (https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/), I was blown away by my own unconscious attitudes and how those attitudes differed from my stated values. Gladwell (2007) points out, "The disturbing thing about the test is that it shows that our unconscious attitudes may be utterly incompatible with our stated conscious values," (p. 355). It's like even when we consciously choose the right path and attitudes, our unconsciousness can get the better of us as we are inundated with cultural messages telling us white is good. It is interesting that we unconsciously form opinions that we otherwise would not have anything to do with. I think we always need to be aware of this as every spontaneous situation has the potential to filter our pro-white associations through. Although I was rated on the Race IAT has having a "moderate automatic preference for whites," I will definitely be more aware of my attitudes and biases as I move forward in life. I think this is important to teach our children as well as they are our future.
Gladwell, M. (2007). Blink in Black and White- Reading #36, 6th Edition.
Wise, T. (2013). Between Barack and a Hard Place - Reading #38, 6th Edition.
Friday, June 27, 2014
Monday, June 23, 2014
Reflection on Reading #33 and #34: The True Meaning of Disability
Reflection on Reading #33: Public Transit by John Hockenberry and Reading #34: "Can You See the Rainbow?" The Roots of Denial by Sally French and Reading #35: Not Blind Enough: Living in the Borderland Called Legal Blindness by Beth Omansky
The articles by John Hockenberry and Sally French really made me ponder the preconceived notions that I have about people with disabilities. I found their articles to be informative and enlightening about the meaning of disability. More specifically, their articles made me think about how being "different" affects people's lives. How can we learn from their experiences and commonalities? And how can we challenge and change these constructions of difference? I'm not sure I have any answers but I believe it is important to keep this dialogue open and moving forward.
We are all shaped by our life experiences. Recognizing the impact our experiences have on our life is not always easy to understand. As I was reading the two articles mentioned above, I was reminded of my own experience living in New York City before moving to Vermont. I thought about how many times I was one of those commuters who stepped around someone in a wheelchair or completely ignored someone who might have needed help using public transit. I thought about all the times I saw someone of color being passed up by a cab driver only to pull up to a white person a block away. Theses were every day occurrences. I see now that these experiences have had an impact on my life. At the time, I saw the injustice of these situations but I just thought, well, that's how life works. "The mass transit system[s] that are inaccessible to wheelchair users 'disable' them by making it difficult or impossible to work, attend school, or manage basic sociability," (Rosenblum & Travis, 2012, p. 6). How could I possibly make a difference in the lives of these individuals? Today I realize that my inaction and blatant ignorance of people with disabilities has made a difference in the lives of these individuals. Hockenberry says, "...I hadn't counted on being completely ignored," (p. 316). And, yet, how many times have I seen this happen? Too many to count. That makes me incredibly sad and ashamed that I have perpetuated this kind of behavior. Isn't it ironic that New York City has millions of people living on top of each other and, yet, it can be one of the most isolating and lonely places out there. I can only imagine how someone bound by cultural stereotypes and disabling environments must feel.
The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (2007) reflects the idea that "disability should be seen as the result of the interaction between a person and his or her environment. Disability is not something that resides in the individual as the result of some impairment...Disability resides in the society, not in the person," (p. 6). This definition extended my thinking about disability and its social constructions and categorizations. In Sally French's article, I was particularly struck by how her interactions with adults really shaped how she viewed and denied her disability. She says, "By denying the reality of my disability I protected myself from the anxiety, disapproval, frustration and disappointment of the adults in my life," (p. 318). This whole idea that she highlights that "the behavior of the adults clearly conveyed the message, 'You are not acceptable as you are,'" (p. 319) is heartbreaking and unimaginable to think about, especially for children. And, yet, we see children in our classrooms desperately seeking approval and acceptance from their peers and adults by denying who they are and the reality of their situations. For example, I worked with a student who was seen as different by his peers and adults because he had Tourette Syndrome. He would often interject humor in between his involuntary facial and vocal tics. Humor had become his way of "dealing with his situation." However, upon reflection, it seems like this was a coping mechanism for this child, a way to adapt and be "normal." As French puts it, "This behavior signals two distinct messages: first that I have failed to be 'normal' (and have therefore failed), and second that I must ask for nothing more," (p. 322). This quote is powerful and shows the challenges that people with disability face on a daily basis. I wonder what it means to be "normal." If we are to celebrate our differences and uniqueness, then nothing and no one can be seen as "normal." I agree with French that "genuine structural and attitudinal change" are needed in order to give the support and encouragement to make the needs known of people with disabilities.
The underlying message of these two articles that we should never deny someone's disability or enable that disability to hide who they are is a powerful one. It is a message that sheds light on the negative stigma of disability. The message reminds us that this whole idea of "normal" is a fallacy in our society that only promotes this image of the "other" who is not at all like "us." As Rosenblum and Travis put it, "Whether in race, sex, sexual orientation, social class, or disability, dichotomization yields a vision of 'them' as profoundly different. Ultimately, dichotomization results in stigmatizing those who are less powerful. It provides the grounds for whole categories of people to become the objects of contempt," (p. 31). It is time to change this mindset so that we can begin to bridge our differences.
French, S. (2008). "Can You See the Rainbow?" The Roots of Denial - Reading #34, 6th Edition.
Hockenberry, J. (1996). Public Transit- Reading #33, 6th Edition.
Omansky, B. (2006). Not Blind Enough: Living in the Borderland Called Legal Blindness- Reading #35, 6th Edition.
Rosenblum, K.E. & Travis, T.M. (2012). The meaning of difference. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
The articles by John Hockenberry and Sally French really made me ponder the preconceived notions that I have about people with disabilities. I found their articles to be informative and enlightening about the meaning of disability. More specifically, their articles made me think about how being "different" affects people's lives. How can we learn from their experiences and commonalities? And how can we challenge and change these constructions of difference? I'm not sure I have any answers but I believe it is important to keep this dialogue open and moving forward.
We are all shaped by our life experiences. Recognizing the impact our experiences have on our life is not always easy to understand. As I was reading the two articles mentioned above, I was reminded of my own experience living in New York City before moving to Vermont. I thought about how many times I was one of those commuters who stepped around someone in a wheelchair or completely ignored someone who might have needed help using public transit. I thought about all the times I saw someone of color being passed up by a cab driver only to pull up to a white person a block away. Theses were every day occurrences. I see now that these experiences have had an impact on my life. At the time, I saw the injustice of these situations but I just thought, well, that's how life works. "The mass transit system[s] that are inaccessible to wheelchair users 'disable' them by making it difficult or impossible to work, attend school, or manage basic sociability," (Rosenblum & Travis, 2012, p. 6). How could I possibly make a difference in the lives of these individuals? Today I realize that my inaction and blatant ignorance of people with disabilities has made a difference in the lives of these individuals. Hockenberry says, "...I hadn't counted on being completely ignored," (p. 316). And, yet, how many times have I seen this happen? Too many to count. That makes me incredibly sad and ashamed that I have perpetuated this kind of behavior. Isn't it ironic that New York City has millions of people living on top of each other and, yet, it can be one of the most isolating and lonely places out there. I can only imagine how someone bound by cultural stereotypes and disabling environments must feel.
The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (2007) reflects the idea that "disability should be seen as the result of the interaction between a person and his or her environment. Disability is not something that resides in the individual as the result of some impairment...Disability resides in the society, not in the person," (p. 6). This definition extended my thinking about disability and its social constructions and categorizations. In Sally French's article, I was particularly struck by how her interactions with adults really shaped how she viewed and denied her disability. She says, "By denying the reality of my disability I protected myself from the anxiety, disapproval, frustration and disappointment of the adults in my life," (p. 318). This whole idea that she highlights that "the behavior of the adults clearly conveyed the message, 'You are not acceptable as you are,'" (p. 319) is heartbreaking and unimaginable to think about, especially for children. And, yet, we see children in our classrooms desperately seeking approval and acceptance from their peers and adults by denying who they are and the reality of their situations. For example, I worked with a student who was seen as different by his peers and adults because he had Tourette Syndrome. He would often interject humor in between his involuntary facial and vocal tics. Humor had become his way of "dealing with his situation." However, upon reflection, it seems like this was a coping mechanism for this child, a way to adapt and be "normal." As French puts it, "This behavior signals two distinct messages: first that I have failed to be 'normal' (and have therefore failed), and second that I must ask for nothing more," (p. 322). This quote is powerful and shows the challenges that people with disability face on a daily basis. I wonder what it means to be "normal." If we are to celebrate our differences and uniqueness, then nothing and no one can be seen as "normal." I agree with French that "genuine structural and attitudinal change" are needed in order to give the support and encouragement to make the needs known of people with disabilities.
The underlying message of these two articles that we should never deny someone's disability or enable that disability to hide who they are is a powerful one. It is a message that sheds light on the negative stigma of disability. The message reminds us that this whole idea of "normal" is a fallacy in our society that only promotes this image of the "other" who is not at all like "us." As Rosenblum and Travis put it, "Whether in race, sex, sexual orientation, social class, or disability, dichotomization yields a vision of 'them' as profoundly different. Ultimately, dichotomization results in stigmatizing those who are less powerful. It provides the grounds for whole categories of people to become the objects of contempt," (p. 31). It is time to change this mindset so that we can begin to bridge our differences.
French, S. (2008). "Can You See the Rainbow?" The Roots of Denial - Reading #34, 6th Edition.
Hockenberry, J. (1996). Public Transit- Reading #33, 6th Edition.
Omansky, B. (2006). Not Blind Enough: Living in the Borderland Called Legal Blindness- Reading #35, 6th Edition.
Rosenblum, K.E. & Travis, T.M. (2012). The meaning of difference. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
Friday, June 20, 2014
Reflection on Reading #45: Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America by Diana Kendall and Reading #46: Loot or Find: Fact or Frame? by Cheryl I. Harris & Devon W. Carbado
Reflection on Reading #45: Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America by Diana Kendall and Reading #46: Loot or Find: Fact or Frame? by Cheryl I. Harris & Devon W. Carbado
Kendall's article highlights the problems of media framing and the impact it has on our every day lives in terms of class, race, and gender. Kendall says, "Rather than providing a meaningful analysis of inequality and showing realistic portrayals of life in various social classes, the media either play class differences for laughs or sweep the issue of class under the rug so that important distinctions are rendered invisible," (p. 448). I thought this observation was rather powerful in light of all the "reality" television that is readily available to view these days. I never thought about how certain shows in the media pit one class against another and this reading really made me ponder that division. For example, I grew up watching The Simpsons and yet I never thought about its portrayal of the working class through what the author calls "caricature framing," (p. 451). Kendall explains that caricature framing "depicts people in negative ways, such as being dumb, white trash, buffoons, bigots, or slobs," (p. 451). While it is true that Homer Simpson, for example, is portrayed as a slob and a buffoon, I never thought about why " situation comedy writers have perpetuated working-class stereotypes," (p. 451). However, it is clear that such depictions, however harmless we think they are, do represent a negative view of people in lower socio-economic classes. As a society, our perceptions of social class are greatly influenced by the media. When the media misrepresents social class, it is our society as a whole that pays the price.
Kendall's article extended my thinking about the concept of framing. Kendall argues that the media rarely discuss class explicitly, but their portrayals of the classes generate perceptions that influence behavior. She illustrates this argument by identifying class-based frames (i.e., representations of the classes). The upper class is generally framed positively in the media: they are composed of everyday individuals who are generous and caring and should be emulated. Even when members of the upper class are framed in a negative light, the media illustrates that upper class criminals have remarkably good lives. We saw this highlighted through the media's coverage of the financial/banking crisis in 2008. Not one executive in the banking industry has been brought to justice thus far. I wonder what is going on here? We also saw this in the media's framing of the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. Someone of color wading through chest deep water with a bag of supplies was considered a looter but the white people doing the exact same thing were "surviving," (p. 454). As Harris and Carbado point out, "so much of public opinion is grounded in misinformation," (p. 455). We interpret the "facts" based on our prior experiences and our frames of reference. Therefore, we see the "facts" as we want to see them and possibly not as they are. This article was eye-opening for me in terms of how our perceptions of the facts are shaped. "...Katrina offers profound insights into how race operates in American society, insights into how various facts about our social life are racially interpreted through frames," (p. 459).
Like the poor, the working class and working poor are often ignored in the media. The working class' relative invisibility results because they are frequently mislabeled as part of the middle class. This seems to impede efforts to develop class awareness because members of the working class typically self-identify as middle class, and this misconception is reinforced in the media. When the working class is visible, diverse frames emerge. The final class discussed in the article is the middle class. Kendall argues that the middle class was historically framed in terms of values, but this frame has increasingly been replaced by negative representations where the middle class is losing its security and standard of living because it is victimized by multiple groups in society, including politicians and criminals.
Kendall argues that media depictions of the classes ignore societal and structural determinants of class positions, causes that are heavily emphasized in the sociological literature. For example, depictions of the upper class ignore economic inequities that generate upper class standing. Likewise, the media rarely consider macro-level causes of impoverishment, such as educational opportunity or underemployment due to economic shifts. This finding certainly points to a need for sociologists to better publicize their research results, making journalists and the public more aware of class-based inequities and structural determinants of these inequities.
Kendall, D. (2011). Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America- Reading #45, 6th Edition.
Harris, C.I. & Carbado, D.W. (2010). Loot or Find: Fact or Frame? - Reading #46, 6th Edition.
Kendall's article highlights the problems of media framing and the impact it has on our every day lives in terms of class, race, and gender. Kendall says, "Rather than providing a meaningful analysis of inequality and showing realistic portrayals of life in various social classes, the media either play class differences for laughs or sweep the issue of class under the rug so that important distinctions are rendered invisible," (p. 448). I thought this observation was rather powerful in light of all the "reality" television that is readily available to view these days. I never thought about how certain shows in the media pit one class against another and this reading really made me ponder that division. For example, I grew up watching The Simpsons and yet I never thought about its portrayal of the working class through what the author calls "caricature framing," (p. 451). Kendall explains that caricature framing "depicts people in negative ways, such as being dumb, white trash, buffoons, bigots, or slobs," (p. 451). While it is true that Homer Simpson, for example, is portrayed as a slob and a buffoon, I never thought about why " situation comedy writers have perpetuated working-class stereotypes," (p. 451). However, it is clear that such depictions, however harmless we think they are, do represent a negative view of people in lower socio-economic classes. As a society, our perceptions of social class are greatly influenced by the media. When the media misrepresents social class, it is our society as a whole that pays the price.
Kendall's article extended my thinking about the concept of framing. Kendall argues that the media rarely discuss class explicitly, but their portrayals of the classes generate perceptions that influence behavior. She illustrates this argument by identifying class-based frames (i.e., representations of the classes). The upper class is generally framed positively in the media: they are composed of everyday individuals who are generous and caring and should be emulated. Even when members of the upper class are framed in a negative light, the media illustrates that upper class criminals have remarkably good lives. We saw this highlighted through the media's coverage of the financial/banking crisis in 2008. Not one executive in the banking industry has been brought to justice thus far. I wonder what is going on here? We also saw this in the media's framing of the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. Someone of color wading through chest deep water with a bag of supplies was considered a looter but the white people doing the exact same thing were "surviving," (p. 454). As Harris and Carbado point out, "so much of public opinion is grounded in misinformation," (p. 455). We interpret the "facts" based on our prior experiences and our frames of reference. Therefore, we see the "facts" as we want to see them and possibly not as they are. This article was eye-opening for me in terms of how our perceptions of the facts are shaped. "...Katrina offers profound insights into how race operates in American society, insights into how various facts about our social life are racially interpreted through frames," (p. 459).
Like the poor, the working class and working poor are often ignored in the media. The working class' relative invisibility results because they are frequently mislabeled as part of the middle class. This seems to impede efforts to develop class awareness because members of the working class typically self-identify as middle class, and this misconception is reinforced in the media. When the working class is visible, diverse frames emerge. The final class discussed in the article is the middle class. Kendall argues that the middle class was historically framed in terms of values, but this frame has increasingly been replaced by negative representations where the middle class is losing its security and standard of living because it is victimized by multiple groups in society, including politicians and criminals.
Kendall argues that media depictions of the classes ignore societal and structural determinants of class positions, causes that are heavily emphasized in the sociological literature. For example, depictions of the upper class ignore economic inequities that generate upper class standing. Likewise, the media rarely consider macro-level causes of impoverishment, such as educational opportunity or underemployment due to economic shifts. This finding certainly points to a need for sociologists to better publicize their research results, making journalists and the public more aware of class-based inequities and structural determinants of these inequities.
Kendall, D. (2011). Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America- Reading #45, 6th Edition.
Harris, C.I. & Carbado, D.W. (2010). Loot or Find: Fact or Frame? - Reading #46, 6th Edition.
Monday, June 16, 2014
Reflection on Reading 12: What's Class Got to Do with It? by Michael Zweig and Reading #13: More or Less Equal? The Economist
Reflection on Reading #12: What's Class Got to Do with
It? by Michael Zweig and Reading #13: More or Less Equal by The Economist
Michael
Zweig's article, What's Class Got to Do with It?, is the author's
examination of class as a central marker in our every day lives. Much
like race and gender, class helps to shape our lives as well as our identity.
Zweig explores class analysis and the understanding of class structure as
a way to demonstrate the defining factor of class: power. The working class,
Zweig says, is composed of people who have "little power or
authority" at work or in our society, (p. 130). As capitalism has
emerged triumphant after the Cold War and as capitalists are asserting their
power more brazenly in the United States and abroad, the issues related to
class have been thrust into the spotlight making the central importance of
class increasingly obvious for everyone to see.
As I was
reading Michael Zweig's article, What's Class Got to Do with It?,
two quotes stood out to me. The first is "[...class can be better
understood] as mainly a question of economic and political power," (p.
130). The second is "Power exists as a relationship between and
among different people or groups," (p. 130). These statements stand
out because they highlight some of the challenges we face in the 21st century.
When we see chief executives paying themselves tens of millions of
dollars while their employees are thrown out of work and denied public
services, we have to wonder if we are all in this together. When working
class people see huge tax cuts going to the wealthiest 1% of our population
while their tiny tax relief is eaten up by the financial crisis, we have to
find a common ground to begin to talk about these issues related to class in
our society. The one thing that mitigates the powerlessness that working
class people feel is our plurality. Zweig says, "in the United
States, working class people are by far the majority of the population.
Over eighty-eight million people were in working class occupations in
2002, comprising 62 percent of the labor force," (p. 131).
Conversely, Zweig points out that capitalists comprise only 2 percent of
the U.S. labor force. That's a huge difference. It tells us that we
need to engage and unify the dormant power of our plurality. In order to
do this we must understand class in terms of power rather than income, wealth,
or lifestyle, although it is true that these do vary by class. Using
powers as the starting point allows us to see class as a dynamic relationship
rather than a static set of characteristics.
It seems
as though the real source with political and economic misdirection in this
country is the increasingly unbridled power of the capitalist class and their
arrogant pursuit of profit for the few at the expense of the vast majority of
Americans and peoples of the world. This should be the target of our politics.
Being rich is not the key point. Conservatives have convinced too many
Americans that their problems stem from government coddling the poor. We need
to redirect this anger, not towards “the rich” but towards the corporate elite.
Such an approach could not be twisted into “threats to rob working people of
their future.” Hopefully, through a national discourse on the subject of class
and power, we can begin to solve the problems associated with it.
Zweig, M. (2004). What's Class Got to Do
with It? - Reading #12, 6th Edition.
The Economist. (2009). More or Less Equal? - Reading #13, 6th Edition.
The Economist. (2009). More or Less Equal? - Reading #13, 6th Edition.
Thursday, June 12, 2014
Reflection on Reading #53: In Defense of Rich Kids by William Upski Wimsatt and Reading #54: Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice by Paul Kivel
Reflection on Reading #53: In Defense of Rich Kids by William Upski Wimsatt and Reading #54: Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice by Paul Kivel
In his article, In Defense of Rich Kids, William Wimsatt reminds us that people are all different and that goes for people with money too. He points out that he is the beneficiary of an unfair system that gives him "tons of free money for doing nothing, yet it forces you to work two and three jobs just to get out of debt," (p. 508). His message is clear that we all need to work together in order to change the political landscape of this country. Changing the political landscape will help to change the unfair systems we have in place that reward the rich and damage the middle class and poor. Wimsatt says that it is more effective for people with money to give to organizing efforts that have little or no financial support rather than to organizations that support bureaucratic institutions that "maintain system problems by treating the symptoms and obscuring root causes," (p. 508). His vision of creating a new kind of organization that will establish new fields of work for social change is risky, but that's the challenge he is willing to take on. He asks that other privileged people with money join him in this effort. He asks that we, as a society, talk about what it means to have money and how we can effectively put that money to good use, rather than not talking about it at all.
Like many people, I have always tried my best to be open and accepting to everyone. However, before I read this article, I have to admit that I had a preconceived notion of this "rich kid." I thought that because he doesn't have to work, he doesn't know what it is like for the rest of us who have to work for a living. However, I had a much different outlook after reading his piece. And it goes back to the idea that we shouldn't judge a book by its cover. It is great to see people who are socioeconomically privileged giving back to our society. I imagine there are more people like him and, accordingly, we shouldn't judge them based on our preconceived notions of what we think all rich people are like. That only perpetuates the cycle of in equality and the idea that all people lumped into the same category are alike, no matter their merits.
In Paul Kivel's article, the author talks about what we can do to work for racial justice. He tells us to take risks, speak up, support, listen and make mistakes. He says, "every situation is different and calls for critical thinking about how to make a difference," (p. 514). This is a good message because every situation is set in a different context and we need to be aware of that in order to generate change or to make a difference. I believe we need to take risks and speak up when we see racism, especially in our classrooms. Teaching our children about racism and that it is good to talk about, rather than avoid it, is critical if we want to change the status quo and our current political system. I know I will work to make these changes in myself and in my children. In order to embrace diversity, we need to work together to build support and establish networks. The issue of racism and discrimination is not going away unless we make it a priority and work together to change it.
Wimsatt, W.U. (1999). In Defense of Rich Kids - Reading #53, 6th Edition.
Kivel, P. (2011). Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice - Reading #54, 6th Edition.
In his article, In Defense of Rich Kids, William Wimsatt reminds us that people are all different and that goes for people with money too. He points out that he is the beneficiary of an unfair system that gives him "tons of free money for doing nothing, yet it forces you to work two and three jobs just to get out of debt," (p. 508). His message is clear that we all need to work together in order to change the political landscape of this country. Changing the political landscape will help to change the unfair systems we have in place that reward the rich and damage the middle class and poor. Wimsatt says that it is more effective for people with money to give to organizing efforts that have little or no financial support rather than to organizations that support bureaucratic institutions that "maintain system problems by treating the symptoms and obscuring root causes," (p. 508). His vision of creating a new kind of organization that will establish new fields of work for social change is risky, but that's the challenge he is willing to take on. He asks that other privileged people with money join him in this effort. He asks that we, as a society, talk about what it means to have money and how we can effectively put that money to good use, rather than not talking about it at all.
Like many people, I have always tried my best to be open and accepting to everyone. However, before I read this article, I have to admit that I had a preconceived notion of this "rich kid." I thought that because he doesn't have to work, he doesn't know what it is like for the rest of us who have to work for a living. However, I had a much different outlook after reading his piece. And it goes back to the idea that we shouldn't judge a book by its cover. It is great to see people who are socioeconomically privileged giving back to our society. I imagine there are more people like him and, accordingly, we shouldn't judge them based on our preconceived notions of what we think all rich people are like. That only perpetuates the cycle of in equality and the idea that all people lumped into the same category are alike, no matter their merits.
In Paul Kivel's article, the author talks about what we can do to work for racial justice. He tells us to take risks, speak up, support, listen and make mistakes. He says, "every situation is different and calls for critical thinking about how to make a difference," (p. 514). This is a good message because every situation is set in a different context and we need to be aware of that in order to generate change or to make a difference. I believe we need to take risks and speak up when we see racism, especially in our classrooms. Teaching our children about racism and that it is good to talk about, rather than avoid it, is critical if we want to change the status quo and our current political system. I know I will work to make these changes in myself and in my children. In order to embrace diversity, we need to work together to build support and establish networks. The issue of racism and discrimination is not going away unless we make it a priority and work together to change it.
Wimsatt, W.U. (1999). In Defense of Rich Kids - Reading #53, 6th Edition.
Kivel, P. (2011). Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice - Reading #54, 6th Edition.
Reflection on Reading 4: Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America by Marie Garroutte and Reading 2: Who is Black? One Nation's Definition by F. James Davis
Reflection on Reading 4: Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America by Marie Garroutte and Reading 2: Who is Black? One Nation's Definition by F. James Davis
Garroutte explores the identity of Native Americans through their citizenship rights and requirements as defined by U.S. law as well as those of specific tribes. It is interesting, but not surprising, that the requirements of each tribe vary from the legal definitions put into place by the U.S. Congress. Garroutte highlights, "Because of these wide variations in legal identity definitions and their frequent departure from the various tribal ones, many individuals who are recognized by their tribes as citizens are nevertheless considered non-Indian for some or all federal purposes," (p. 67). Garroutte does a good job of documenting how these requirements have been manipulated by the federal government, by trial officials, and by Indian and non-Indian individuals to gain political, social, or economic advantage.
After reading this article and the article on "Who is Black? One Nation's Definition" by F. James Davis, I am struck and perplexed by all these arbitrary rules that we have to determine a person's racial and ethnic identity. It is crazy to me that we are still using antiquated systems and definitions to determine a person's ancestry. Davis points out, "Not only does the one-drop rule apply to no other group than American blacks, but apparently the rule is unique in that it is found in the United States and not in any other nation in the world," (p. 62). This is appalling to me. And it makes me wonder what makes me "white"? As far as I know, I pass the one-drop rule test and yet I have never been identified as anything other than white or Caucasian. It is interesting because a genetic test might show something else entirely so what's "correct?" Does social pressure dictate this?
This entire discussion on race is interesting and uncomfortable at times. However, I believe it is something that we should be addressing in our schools with our students. I wonder how many Americans realize how we define certain groups, like Native Americans and Black Americans. As Davis points out, "Most Americans seem unaware that this definition of blacks is extremely unusual in other countries, perhaps even unique to the United States, and that Americans define no other minority group in a similar way..." (p. 63). How can this still be in the 21st century? How can we find a way to talk about this with others in a way that is productive when the concepts underlying biological definitions of identity are so far from common sense, as Garroutte reminds us (p. 69)?
Garroutte, M. (2012). Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America - Reading #4, 6th Edition.
Davis, F.J. (2012). Who is Black? One Nation's Definition - Reading #2, 6th Edition.
Garroutte explores the identity of Native Americans through their citizenship rights and requirements as defined by U.S. law as well as those of specific tribes. It is interesting, but not surprising, that the requirements of each tribe vary from the legal definitions put into place by the U.S. Congress. Garroutte highlights, "Because of these wide variations in legal identity definitions and their frequent departure from the various tribal ones, many individuals who are recognized by their tribes as citizens are nevertheless considered non-Indian for some or all federal purposes," (p. 67). Garroutte does a good job of documenting how these requirements have been manipulated by the federal government, by trial officials, and by Indian and non-Indian individuals to gain political, social, or economic advantage.
After reading this article and the article on "Who is Black? One Nation's Definition" by F. James Davis, I am struck and perplexed by all these arbitrary rules that we have to determine a person's racial and ethnic identity. It is crazy to me that we are still using antiquated systems and definitions to determine a person's ancestry. Davis points out, "Not only does the one-drop rule apply to no other group than American blacks, but apparently the rule is unique in that it is found in the United States and not in any other nation in the world," (p. 62). This is appalling to me. And it makes me wonder what makes me "white"? As far as I know, I pass the one-drop rule test and yet I have never been identified as anything other than white or Caucasian. It is interesting because a genetic test might show something else entirely so what's "correct?" Does social pressure dictate this?
This entire discussion on race is interesting and uncomfortable at times. However, I believe it is something that we should be addressing in our schools with our students. I wonder how many Americans realize how we define certain groups, like Native Americans and Black Americans. As Davis points out, "Most Americans seem unaware that this definition of blacks is extremely unusual in other countries, perhaps even unique to the United States, and that Americans define no other minority group in a similar way..." (p. 63). How can this still be in the 21st century? How can we find a way to talk about this with others in a way that is productive when the concepts underlying biological definitions of identity are so far from common sense, as Garroutte reminds us (p. 69)?
Garroutte, M. (2012). Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of Native America - Reading #4, 6th Edition.
Davis, F.J. (2012). Who is Black? One Nation's Definition - Reading #2, 6th Edition.
Monday, June 9, 2014
Reflection on Reading 1: "Race" and the Construction of Human Identity by Audrey Smedley
Reflection on Reading 1: "Race" and the Construction of Human Identity by Audrey Smedley
As I was reading Audrey Smedley's article about the historical and social constructions of identity, I thought about the following quote by the Roman orator Cicero, "History...provides guidance in daily life, and brings us tidings of antiquity," (Samovar, 2012, p. 40). I believe Cicero was correct that all cultures believe in the idea that history provides stories about the past that serve as lessons on how to live in the present. History highlights the culture's origins, "tells" its members what is deemed important, and identifies the accomplishments of the culture of which they can be proud. However, sometimes history has not been so kind to certain human identities based on external physical features and the imposed social meaning of those physical features. Smedley's article is a fascinating look into the modern conceptions of race and human identity. She points out that people of the ancient world understood that ethnic identity itself was dynamic and changeable. Smedley (1998) says, "Populations did not necessarily lose any form of ethnic identity, but change was clearly understood as virtually inevitable as each society learned something new from the cultures of others...," (p. 46). This is a fascinating point since it seems as though we look at identity today as something that is unmalleable and constant. It is striking that biological differences among human groups were not given meaning in the ancient world because today biological differences pervade the concept of human identity as markers of social status.
I agree with Smedley and most scholars today that "race is nothing more and nothing less than a social invention," (p. 53). In fact, race has nothing to do with the superficial physical differences upon which is was imposed and everything to do with power, privilege, and wealth - who has it and who does not. Once we begin to understand the real nature of race as a social construct can we begin to deal with the implications that racial and ethnic identities have imposed on various groups of people. As we have seen throughout history, ethical standards vary from culture to culture and are subject to change. As we shift towards a more globalized world, perhaps, our standards and norms will converge and lead to common values regarding our understanding of human identity. I like the idea of "universal" human beings. I believe this idea will help us move forward in recognizing identity as fluid and multicultural.
It is interesting to see how the concept of race has emerged throughout history. As such, it makes me think about how conceptions could be different if historical events followed a different path. I believe Shannon brought this up in class and I thought it was a fascinating idea: what if the colonial revolt known as Bacon's Rebellion in 1676 had succeeded? Would we have different ways of looking at racial ideology and the arbitrary rankings of people associated with it? I wonder...
Smedley, A. (1998). "Race" and the Construction of Human Identity - Reading #1, 6th Edition
As I was reading Audrey Smedley's article about the historical and social constructions of identity, I thought about the following quote by the Roman orator Cicero, "History...provides guidance in daily life, and brings us tidings of antiquity," (Samovar, 2012, p. 40). I believe Cicero was correct that all cultures believe in the idea that history provides stories about the past that serve as lessons on how to live in the present. History highlights the culture's origins, "tells" its members what is deemed important, and identifies the accomplishments of the culture of which they can be proud. However, sometimes history has not been so kind to certain human identities based on external physical features and the imposed social meaning of those physical features. Smedley's article is a fascinating look into the modern conceptions of race and human identity. She points out that people of the ancient world understood that ethnic identity itself was dynamic and changeable. Smedley (1998) says, "Populations did not necessarily lose any form of ethnic identity, but change was clearly understood as virtually inevitable as each society learned something new from the cultures of others...," (p. 46). This is a fascinating point since it seems as though we look at identity today as something that is unmalleable and constant. It is striking that biological differences among human groups were not given meaning in the ancient world because today biological differences pervade the concept of human identity as markers of social status.
I agree with Smedley and most scholars today that "race is nothing more and nothing less than a social invention," (p. 53). In fact, race has nothing to do with the superficial physical differences upon which is was imposed and everything to do with power, privilege, and wealth - who has it and who does not. Once we begin to understand the real nature of race as a social construct can we begin to deal with the implications that racial and ethnic identities have imposed on various groups of people. As we have seen throughout history, ethical standards vary from culture to culture and are subject to change. As we shift towards a more globalized world, perhaps, our standards and norms will converge and lead to common values regarding our understanding of human identity. I like the idea of "universal" human beings. I believe this idea will help us move forward in recognizing identity as fluid and multicultural.
It is interesting to see how the concept of race has emerged throughout history. As such, it makes me think about how conceptions could be different if historical events followed a different path. I believe Shannon brought this up in class and I thought it was a fascinating idea: what if the colonial revolt known as Bacon's Rebellion in 1676 had succeeded? Would we have different ways of looking at racial ideology and the arbitrary rankings of people associated with it? I wonder...
Smedley, A. (1998). "Race" and the Construction of Human Identity - Reading #1, 6th Edition
Samovar,
L., Porter, R.E. and McDaniel, E.R. (2013).
Communication between cultures,
8Ed.
Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)